Exit poll results were projected on BBC headquarters last week after polls closed in the general election. Photo / AP
The prime minister and his party question the broadcaster's reliance on fees paid by viewers. They are increasingly at odds with its journalism, too.
The British Broadcasting Corp. has long been one of Britain's most revered institutions. But after an election campaign in which it faced charges of bias, the media organisation finds its future in the hands of some of its biggest critics.
Prime Minister Boris Johnson, coming off a resounding victory for his Conservative Party, raised questions during the campaign about the BBC's fundamental source of revenue — the license fee charged to all television viewers in the country.
Evidence of his antipathy has been reinforced since the election by reports that he has barred Cabinet ministers from appearing on an influential BBC radio program.
"Although there's been pressure from both sides of the political divide on the BBC, it feels as if the current administration is more likely to act and do something drastic than a prior government would have been able to," said Richard Broughton, the research director at Ampere Analysis, a London-based firm focused on analysis of media and communications.
The BBC's staid and trusted reputation has earned it the nickname "Auntie." But the Conservatives have for years reproached it for using taxpayer money to compete with private companies.
"You have to ask yourself whether that approach to funding a media company still makes sense in the long term given the way that other organisations manage to fund themselves," Johnson said on the campaign trail last week.
It has been increasingly evident, however, that the friction goes beyond the BBC's business model and extends to its journalism, as the prime minister delivers broadsides — evocative of President Donald Trump's media criticism — against the broadcaster.
Earlier this year, while maneuvering to be the Conservative leader, he denounced the BBC over its coverage of Britain's prospective departure from the European Union, referring to it as "the Brexit Bashing Corp."
Johnson has never been one to shy from a fight. On Monday, moving into a contentious dispute, he said his government would try to ban local authorities from taking part in the boycott-Israel movement.
But Claire Enders, the founder of the telecommunications and media research firm Enders Analysis, said Johnson's "Trumpian manner" toward the BBC and other broadcasters over their news coverage was without precedent.
"This is a very new concept that Boris seems to have — that somehow he can dictate to them what the agenda is and that they have no standing as institutions either here or in the global space," she said.
Over the weekend, local British news organisations reported that Cabinet ministers would boycott the BBC radio program Today, whose tough questioning of government officials often sets the day's political news agenda. The Guardian and The Mail on Sunday said Johnson's office would "withdraw engagement" with the program going forward.
The prime minister's office did not respond to requests for comment for this article.
The BBC responded to the reports, saying, "Our aim throughout the election was to be on the side of the audience, who came to us in their millions."
"We'll continue to make our own editorial decisions and report without fear or favor," it added.
The BBC is not alone in the cross hairs. Johnson's party also complained to the country's broadcasting regulator after a competitor, Channel 4, chose to have a block of melting ice at its debate over the climate, in lieu of Johnson, who had declined to take part.
These two ice sculptures - which represent the emergency on planet earth - will take the place of Boris Johnson and Nigel Farage tonight after they declined our invitation to attend a party leaders' #ClimateDebate
— Channel 4 News (@Channel4News) November 28, 2019
Tune in at 7pm on 4 and here on Twitter: https://t.co/GXl7XiFbgA pic.twitter.com/niPE5MLdGV
And the Tories are not the only ones to find fault with the BBC's coverage. After their devastating election defeat last week, Labour Party members have cast some of the blame on the media, including the BBC.
"Labour attacks it and Boris attacks it," Enders said. "It's the cognitive dissonance of occupying the center."
Andy McDonald, a Labour lawmaker, accused the BBC on Monday of bias against his party. "If the BBC are going to hold themselves out as somehow having conducted themselves in an impartial manner, I think they've really got to have a look in the mirror," he said on the Today program.
‘History will look back and give a good account of Jeremy Corbyn'
— BBC Radio 5 Live (@bbc5live) December 16, 2019
Labour’s @AndyMcDonaldMP says Corbyn was ‘demonised’ by the media.
📲 Read more: https://t.co/Sn8tfC9PrF#5LiveBreakfast 🎧 Listen on @BBCSounds pic.twitter.com/I3D4e9jqdv
But it is the Conservatives, with their huge majority, who will have the political clout to jeopardise the BBC's funding.
While the BBC, founded in 1922, has independent control of its programming, it is subject to government scrutiny of its finances and the terms of its charter.
Rishi Sunak, the chief secretary to the Treasury, said over the weekend — on a BBC television program — that Johnson had asked for a review of the enforcement of the license fee, an annual payment of 154.50 pounds (about $310) that is made by most households that own a television in Britain. Those who do not pay it can face a penalty of as much as 1,000 pounds as well as being forced to cover legal costs.
"I think it's fair to say people find the criminalisation of nonpayment of the license fee to be something that has provoked questions in the past," Sunak said.
The license fee generates about 3.6 billion pounds a year for the broadcaster, making up about 75 per cent of its funding. Without enforcement, the BBC estimates that it could lose 200 million pounds of that revenue each year. In a statement, it pointed out that the government had already commissioned a review of the matter from a lawyer who found that the current system should be maintained.
Perhaps the most outspoken Conservative critic of the BBC is John Whittingdale, a former culture secretary, who has suggested that the corporation should become smaller and less costly and compete less with private media companies.
"With so much more choice in what to consume and how to consume it, we must at least question whether the BBC should try to be all things to all people, to serve everyone over every platform or if it should have a more precisely targeted mission," he told Parliament in 2015.
He also told students the following year that he was "driven insane" by the way the BBC deals with complaints about impartiality and how it treated those favoring Britain's exit from the European Union as "faintly mad."
Talking about not renewing the BBC's charter, he said, "It may be that the BBC will cease to exist, which is occasionally a tempting prospect."
Written by: Amie Tsang
© 2019 THE NEW YORK TIMES
Six people have now died in a suspected mass methanol poisoning event.