President Donald Trump throws a hat to supporters as he arrives to speak at a campaign rally at Altoona-Blair County Airport in Martinsburg, Pennsylvania. Photo / AP
As the national early vote climbs past a staggering 93 million and challenges to the electoral process intensify across states, President Donald Trump and Joe Biden are barreling into Pennsylvania and turning it into the top battleground in Wednesday's election, with Democrats flooding in with door-knockers and Republicans trying to parlay Trump's rallies into big turnout once again.
Both campaigns see Pennsylvania as increasingly crucial to victory: Trump now appears more competitive here than in Michigan and Wisconsin, two other key northern states he hopes to win, and Biden's clearest electoral path to the White House runs through the state. Pennsylvania has more Electoral College votes, 20, than any other traditional battleground except Florida, and Trump won the state by less than 1 percentage point in 2016.
Trump devoted Sunday to four rallies across the state, and he and Biden planned campaign events for the final 48 hours of the race as well, with a wave of prominent Democrats and celebrities slated to arrive. On Tuesday the president was set to make an appeal to white, working-class voters in Scranton, where Biden was born, while the Democratic nominee was aiming to solidify a broad coalition of white suburbanites and voters of colour on a two-day swing through Philadelphia, Pittsburgh and elsewhere in western Pennsylvania.
Biden is ahead with a modest margin in recent polls, and is trying to cut into the president's turnout in rural counties. But Trump's rallies have energised many Republican voters, and his team is already preparing legal challenges over the vote if it ends up being close.
In Pennsylvania in particular, the possibility of extended court battles and confusion hangs over the race, with the state Republican Party hoping the Supreme Court will reconsider its decision last week to allow the state to continue receiving absentee ballots for three days after Election Day.
"Every day is a new reminder of how high the stakes are, how far the other side will go to try to suppress the turnout," Biden said as he campaigned here today. "Especially here in Philadelphia. President Trump is terrified of what will happen in Pennsylvania."
Court battles have already rearranged the voting process across an array of states and continued to do so. The Texas Supreme Court denied an effort by Republicans to throw out more than 120,000 votes that had been cast at drive-through locations in Harris County, an increasingly Democratic area anchored in Houston. Republicans are now hoping for a favourable ruling at the federal level, where a judge has called an election-eve hearing for Tuesday.
Some Trump supporters also turned disruptive today: Vehicles bearing Trump flags halted traffic on the Garden State Parkway in New Jersey; local officials said the motorcade backed up traffic for several miles. In Georgia, a rally for Democrats that had been scheduled was canceled, with organisers citing worries over what they feared was a "large militia presence" drawn by Trump's own event nearby.
Throughout his final sprint of rallies, Trump has moved to baselessly sow doubt about the integrity of the electoral process. At an appearance in Dubuque, Iowa, Trump claimed, inaccurately, that the result of the election was always determined on Election Day. "We should know the result of the election on November 3," he said. "The evening of Nov. 3. That's the way it's been and that's the way it should be. What's going on in this country?"
Biden countered with his own warning today, saying, "The president is not going to steal this election."
Trump's lagging position in the race was evident in his gruelling travel schedule that had him shoring up votes in five states he won four years ago — Michigan, Iowa, North Carolina, Georgia and Florida.
His final rally of the day was scheduled for 11 pm, and risked violating a midnight curfew in Miami-Dade County.
Biden, by contrast, set his sights squarely on Pennsylvania today, an approach he will repeat again tomorrow, along with a foray into Ohio, a state Trump won handily in 2016 but that polls show could be more competitive now.
The Biden campaign was intensifying its push in Pennsylvania, encouraging supporters from out of state to join canvassing efforts that for months it had sworn off because of the health risks. The campaign said that volunteers had knocked on more than 350,000 doors on Sunday, and made 2 million calls and sent 1.5 million text messages to voters in the state.
Compared with other swing states, such as Florida, far fewer early ballots have already been cast in Pennsylvania and, according to the U.S. Elections Project, as of today there were more than 350,000 absentee ballots that had been requested by Democratic voters that had yet to be returned. The Biden campaign is focused on the fact that a large share of the electorate here is still expected to vote on Election Day, an adviser said.
The final sprint of the race came against a different backdrop than in previous elections, with fewer voters left to motivate. The record number of early votes underscored the intense interest in one of the most consequential elections in modern history, despite the logistical challenges of voting amid a pandemic.
Biden spent today afternoon with Black voters at a drive-in "Souls to the Polls" event at a Philadelphia church. His outreach came as Democrats have worried about his ability to sufficiently energise and turn out Black and Latino Democratic voters in some states. He addressed another drive-in rally in the city in the evening, reminding voters of their influence over the outcome.
Trump, for his part, made his own pitch to Black voters while campaigning in Hickory, North Carolina. "To every Black American, I am asking you to vote on Tuesday," he said, projecting confidence about his own standing with Black voters.
Biden's Philadelphia events kicked off a last push through the state over the final two days. Tomorrow, Biden, Sen. Kamala Harris and their spouses are expected to campaign in five media markets, hoping to cement support across a sprawling coalition and to keep Trump's margins down in parts of western Pennsylvania that propelled him to victory in 2016.
"My message is simple," Biden said today. "Pennsylvania is critical in this election."
Democrats are well aware of how devoted Trump's core base remains. In Macomb County in Michigan, where the president held his first rally today, Irwin Patterson was selling Trump merchandise at a makeshift roadside store.
"In Michigan here, just our little part of Michigan, the support that we see here is just insane," he said, as windblown snow pelted his customers. "I mean, for the last month and a half, it's just been off the hook."
Still, Trump had work to do all over the country shoring up his support in states he won four years ago. In Michigan, Trump complained repeatedly about the freezing temperature and biting wind he said was pointed "directly" at his face while making false claims about resuscitating the auto industry there. He also embraced the actions of some of his supporters in Texas who had surrounded a Biden campaign bus with their vehicles on Sunday, in an apparent attempt to slow it down and run it off the road. Trump claimed the vehicles were "protecting his bus, yesterday, because they are nice."
Later, he tweeted in response to the news that the FBI was investigating the incident that "in my opinion, these patriots did nothing wrong," adding that federal authorities should be scrutinising antifa instead.
Of the three big Northern swing states Trump won by a hair four years ago, the once reliably blue state of Pennsylvania is the one his advisers believe is most likely within his reach. That's in large part because of the support of rural voters and Biden's call for eventually phasing out fossil fuels, an unpopular stance for many voters in a state with a large natural gas industry.
Trump entered the final hours of the race in a worse position here than he was four years ago, when Pennsylvania was seen as Hillary Rodham Clinton's firewall. This time, Biden has a lead of 6 points there, according to a new New York Times/Siena College poll released today, and is working to create multiple pathways to 270 electoral votes.
That lead, however, isn't enough to make Democrats and anti-Trump Republicans feel fully confident about the state of the race in Pennsylvania. Some of the president's opponents in recent days have been worried about turnout in the state's rural counties, as well as calls about requested ballots that never arrived.
The Trump campaign ads running in Pennsylvania have been overwhelmingly centred on economic messages, mainly jobs and taxes. The campaign's most aired ad in Pennsylvania over the past week has been a negative ad claiming Biden will raise taxes (he has said he will raise taxes for those making over US$400,000).
But the Biden campaign has not ceded the subject to the president, with 14 different ads on air that touch on jobs and the economy. Its most aired ad in Pennsylvania over the past week featured a Biden speech outlining his plans for pandemic recovery, including jobs. Another ad directly rebuts the Trump campaign's attacks on his tax plan.
Pennsylvania's economy is emerging from the pandemic recession but still has a long road ahead to its precrisis state. Like the nation, it has seen a two-track recovery that has left small businesses and low-earning workers behind.
Pennsylvania saw its unemployment rate fall to 8.1 per cent in September, according to the Labor Department, nearly identical to the national rate of 7.9 per cent. That is a significant improvement from the 16.1 per cent unemployment it posted in April. But the state still had 380,000 fewer jobs in September than it did in September of 2019, and there are 18 per cent fewer small businesses open here compared to a year ago, according to data compiled by the economists at Opportunity Insights.
Pennsylvania has long loomed large in the psyche of the Biden campaign. Biden, a Scranton native, gave his first speech of his presidential campaign in Pittsburgh, and he chose Philadelphia for his campaign headquarters, before the pandemic hit.
"That blue wall has to be reestablished," Biden said in another recent Pennsylvania campaign appearance. He said that winning the state meant a "great deal to me, personally as well as politically."
Written by: Katie Glueck and Annie Karni
© 2020 THE NEW YORK TIMES
Six people have now died in a suspected mass methanol poisoning event.