Protesters outside the Supreme Court in December. Many Republican grass-roots donors were drawn in by Trump's false promises after the November election. Photo / Anna Moneymaker, The New York Times
With breathless, often misleading appeals, the former president promised small donors that he was using the money to fight the election results, but in fact stored much of it for future use.
Former President Donald Trump and the Republican Party leveraged false claims of voter fraud and promises to overturn the election to raise more than a quarter-billion dollars in November and December as hundreds of thousands of trusting supporters listened and opened their wallets.
But the Trump campaign spent only a tiny fraction of its haul on lawyers and other legal bills related to those claims. Instead, Trump and the GOP stored away much of the money — US$175 million ($244 million) or so — even as they continued to issue breathless, aggressive and often misleading appeals for cash that promised it would help with recounts, the rooting out of election fraud and even the Republican candidates' chances in the two Senate runoff races in Georgia.
What fraction of the money Trump did spend after the election was ploughed mostly into a public-relations campaign and to keep his perpetual fundraising machine whirring, with nearly US$50 million ($70 million) going toward online advertising, text-message outreach and a small television ad campaign.
Only about US$10 million spent by Trump's campaign went to actual legal costs, according to an analysis of new Federal Election Commission filings from November 4 through the end of the year.
Far more is now sitting in the coffers of a new political action committee, Save America, that Trump formed after the election and that provides him a fat war chest he can use to pay advisers, fund travel and maintain a political operation. Trump's new PAC had US$31 million in the bank at the end of 2020 and an estimated US$40 million more sitting in a shared party account waiting to be transferred into it.
Trump's extraordinary success raising money came mostly from grassroots and online contributors drawn to his lie that the election result would soon be somehow wiped away. Only about a dozen donors gave US$25,000 or more to one of Trump's committees after November 24. (The lone six-figure donation came from Elaine J. Wold, a major Republican donor in Florida.)
"Sophisticated donors are not dumb," said Dan Eberhart, a major Republican donor who has supported Trump in the past. "They could see through what Trump was trying to do."
A spokesperson for Trump did not respond to a request for comment.
One of the few five-figure checks deposited in December came from the National Fraternal Order of Police PAC. But its executive director, James Pasco, said the group had actually issued the US$25,000 donation in early November. He said he did not know why it hadn't been cashed until December.
"The optics of this are terrible," Pasco lamented. "We in no way questioned the election at any point, or were involved in an effort to forestall the results."
Still, many Republican grassroots donors were drawn in by Trump's false promises and "stop the steal" message. He fomented intense opposition to the inauguration of President Joe Biden, which eventually culminated in the January 6 riot at the Capitol as flag-waving Trump supporters violently sought to disrupt the certification of Biden's victory.
All told, more than 2 million donations flowed to the former president and his shared committees with the Republican National Committee from November 24 to the end of the year. Trump's fundraising did stall drastically after the Electoral College certified Biden as the winner on December 14.
In the two weeks leading up to that day, Trump and the RNC had raised an average of US$2.9 million every day online; in the two weeks after, the average was US$1.2 million, according to records from WinRed, the Republican digital donation platform.
Despite that slowdown, Trump still outpaced the online fundraising of the two Republican senators, Kelly Loeffler and David Perdue, who were competing in the Georgia runoff elections that would determine control of the chamber in the last 39 days of the year, which the most recent federal filings cover.
Trump and his shared committees with the RNC raised US$80 million online during that period; Loeffler and Perdue combined for closer to US$75 million. Both Senate candidates lost.
"Absolutely that money was misdirected," Eberhart said. "I would have loved to see half that money go to the Georgia Senate races."
Trump's campaign appears to have contributed nothing to the Georgia races, despite fundraising appeals that emphasised the importance of the races; the RNC reported $7.9 million in expenditures aiding Loeffler and Perdue.
A host of corporations and major donors mostly ignored Trump in the weeks after the election and poured money instead into the Georgia runoffs. Donations included a US$5 million check from the American Petroleum Institute and hundreds of thousands more from oil giants like Chevron and Valero, which were fearful of the impact of a Democratic-controlled Senate.
Kenneth Griffin, CEO of financial firm Citadel, donated US$10 million to the main Senate Republican super PAC in November. Griffin's firm now faces scrutiny for some of its investments related to the GameStop stock that soared last month in a Reddit-driven populist revolt.
Stephen A. Schwarzman, CEO of private equity giant Blackstone, who has known Trump for decades and donated to him in the past, said publicly by mid-November that Biden had most likely won. Around that time, he gave US$15 million to the same Senate Republican super PAC focused on Georgia.
"The outcome is very certain today, and the country should move on," Schwarzman said in late November.
Trump did incur some legal costs, though there were no disclosed payments to some of the best-known figures in his failed legal fight, including Sidney Powell, the lawyer who spread conspiracy theories and held one news conference in the lobby of the RNC, and Rudy Giuliani, the former president's personal lawyer.
Giuliani's firm was reimbursed for US$63,423 in travel in mid-December. (Another firm run by an ally of Giuliani, former New York police Commissioner Bernard B. Kerik, was also paid US$20,130 in travel reimbursements; Trump pardoned Kerik last year for his 2010 conviction on eight felonies.)
All told, the Trump campaign paid more than a dozen law firms, including US$1.6 million to Kasowitz Benson Torres, more than US$500,000 to Jones Day and about US$600,000 to Dechert. The law firm of Kurt Hilbert, who was on Trump's phone call pressuring the Republican secretary of state in Georgia, Brad Raffensperger, to "find" votes to overturn the election outcome, was paid more than US$480,000. A US$3 million payment went to the Wisconsin Elections Commission to pay for a recount.
One major Republican donor, C. Boyden Gray, who contributed more than US$2 million to Republicans in the 2020 cycle, also provided legal consulting for Trump, earning US$114,000.
The Trump operation continued to spend on fundraising, pouring millions into a secretive limited liability company, American Made Media Consultants, for online and text-message advertising. Family members of Trump and Vice President Mike Pence once served on the board of the company, which had more than US$700 million in spending flow through it during the 2020 campaign.
In the post election period, more than US$63 million in spending flowed through the company from committees linked to Trump.
The Republican National Committee ended the year with more than US$80 million in the bank after the fundraising blitz, and the party is entitled to a share of the US$63 million more in two shared accounts with Trump. Per an agreement, the RNC collected 25 cents for every dollar Trump raised online through their joint account in December.
One of Trump's shared committees with the RNC spent nearly US$235,000 on books through a company, Reagan Investments, that has also done work for a PAC controlled by Senator Ted Cruz of Texas. The Trump campaign offered signed copies of a book by Cruz last fall to donors who gave US$75 or more.
And, as they have since the beginning of his candidacy in 2015, Trump's campaign accounts patronised his businesses in the post election period.
The Trump Victory committee paid US$34,000 to the Trump Hotel Collection in its final 2020 filing. The same committee also paid a Trump-owned limited liability company that operates a private plane, DT Endeavor, US$39,200 on November 24.
Another Trump campaign committee paid US$75,000 in rent to the Trump Tower building in December.
Written by: Shane Goldmacher and Rachel Shorey
Photographs by: Doug Mills and Anna Moneymaker
© 2021 THE NEW YORK TIMES
New York Times: Ballot boxes burn as America faces unprecedented election violence.