People walk past the ruins of buildings destroyed in airstrikes on Yemen. The Trump administration is preparing to circumvent Congress to allow the export of munitions. Photo / Tyler Hicks, NY Times
The Trump administration is preparing to circumvent Congress to allow the export to Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates of billions of dollars worth of munitions that are now on hold, according to current and former US officials and legislators familiar with the plan.
Secretary of State Mike Pompeo and other senior aides are pushing for the administration to invoke an emergency provision that would allow President Donald Trump to prevent Congress from halting the sales, worth about US$7 billion. The transactions, which include precision-guided munitions and combat aircraft, would infuriate lawmakers in both parties.
They would also further inflame tensions between the United States and Iran, which views Saudi Arabia as its main rival and has been supporting the Houthi rebels in Yemen in their campaign against a Saudi-led military coalition that includes the UAE.
US legislators from both parties remain incensed by the Trump administration's equivocal response to the grisly killing last October by Saudi agents of Jamal Khashoggi, a Washington Post columnist and Virginia resident. They are also frustrated by the administration's role in supporting the Saudi-led coalition in the Yemen war, a four-year conflict that the United Nations has deemed the world's worst humanitarian crisis, with thousands of civilians killed and millions suffering from famine.
This spring, both the House and Senate approved bipartisan legislation to cut off military assistance to Saudi Arabia's war in Yemen using the 1973 War Powers Act, only to see it vetoed in April.
Senator Marco Rubio, R-Fla., who sits on the Foreign Relations Committee, said that circumventing Congress on a Middle East arms sale would be "a big mistake," though he added that he would need to see the specifics of such a deal.
"We have a gold standard for that sort of arrangement, and to violate it for Saudi Arabia is going to open the door for it to happen in multiple other places," he said.
Senator Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., an outspoken ally of the president, told reporters Thursday that he would "not do business as usual with the Saudis until we have a better reckoning" with the crown prince, Mohammed bin Salman, whom US intelligence agencies consider to be responsible for the killing of Khashoggi and the Saudi role in the Yemen war.
No other foreign policy issue has created as large a rift between Trump and Congress, and the move on the arms sales, which could take place within days, would deepen the divide. Pompeo would oversee the action, and the State Department is bracing for lawmakers to stall confirmations on all State Department nominees if it is implemented. Within the department, veteran Foreign Service officers have strongly opposed Pompeo's position.
The proposal emerged publicly Wednesday when Senator Chris Murphy, D-Conn., criticised it on Twitter.
REALLY IMPORTANT THREAD: 1/ I am hearing that Trump may use an obscure loophole in the Arms Control Act and notice a major new sale of bombs to Saudi Arabia (the ones they drop in Yemen) in a way that will prevent Congress from objecting. Could happen this week.
— Chris Murphy (@ChrisMurphyCT) May 22, 2019
Members of Congress ordinarily are given a review period during which they can pass legislation modifying or prohibiting a prospective arms sale. But a provision in the Arms Export Control Act allows the president to bypass congressional review if he deems "an emergency exists which requires the proposed sale in the national security interest of the United States."
"It sets an incredibly dangerous precedent that future presidents can use to sell weapons without a check from Congress," Murphy said in an interview Friday. "We have the constitutional duty to declare war and the responsibility to oversee arm sales that contravene our national security interests. If we don't stand up to this abuse of authority, we will permanently box ourselves out of deciding who we should sell weapons to."
Senator Robert Menendez of New Jersey, the top Democrat on the Foreign Relations Committee, warned that he would "pursue all appropriate legislative and other means to nullify these and any planned ongoing sales should the administration move forward in this manner."
Menendez withheld his support last summer for a Trump administration plan to sell precision-guided munitions to Saudi Arabia and the UAE, effectively blocking it.
Pompeo's emergency declaration would be based on what he says is a heightened threat against American interests in the region from Iran. Pompeo took the extraordinary step this month of ordering a withdrawal of almost all US diplomats from the Baghdad embassy and Erbil consulate in Iraq. European allies and Iraqi leaders have expressed scepticism about American alarm over Iran.
Asked about the proposal, Morgan Ortagus, the main State Department spokeswoman, said, "We do not comment to confirm or deny potential arms sales or transfers until Congress is formally notified."
Tensions between the United States and Iran have soared since May 5, when John Bolton, the national security adviser and an Iran hawk, announced that the White House was ordering an aircraft carrier strike group and bombers to speed up their movement to the Persian Gulf. In the days afterward, US officials told reporters that they had gotten several strands of intelligence about potential attacks on US troops or diplomats by Iranian forces or Arab militias with Iranian ties.
Bolton issued an expansive warning against Iran, saying that "any attack on United States interests or on those of our allies will be met with unrelenting force." Critics of the escalation, which was supported by Pompeo, said the Trump administration had provoked Iran by withdrawing from a 2015 nuclear containment deal, reimposing harsh sanctions and designating an arm of the Iranian military as a terrorist organization.
Tensions in the Persian Gulf also rose this month after four oil tankers were attacked with explosives. Two of the tankers are from Saudi Arabia, one is from the UAE and the fourth is from Norway; the countries have not revealed the results of investigations, but Pompeo said this week, without presenting evidence, that it was "quite possible that Iran was behind these."
Lawmakers have never successfully blocked an arms sale through the passage of a joint resolution when the president has invoked a national security justification, according to Melissa Dalton, the director of the Cooperative Defense Project at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, and instead have typically registered their disapproval privately.
But the invocation of the emergency provision is "pretty unusual," Dalton said, because "normally Congress has a good sense of what is coming. Typically there isn't any surprise or need to invoke this unless there has been some controversy in the broader bilateral relationship."
On Friday, the acting defense secretary, Patrick Shanahan, said Trump might send more troops to the Middle East because of the tensions with Iran.
"The US and Iran are entering into an escalatory dynamic from which it will become increasingly difficult to escape," said Robert Malley, the president of the International Crisis Group, a nonprofit that tries to defuse conflict.
Dalia Dassa Kaye, a Middle East analyst at RAND Corp., a research group, said, "Pushing through arms sales at this moment would not just escalate tensions with Congress but also with Iran, and likely undermine peace efforts in Yemen."
The end run around Congress would come just weeks before the White House is expected to unveil a plan to end the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Trump's son-in-law and main Middle East adviser, Jared Kushner, is seeking support from Saudi Arabia and other Arab nations for the plan, which will probably include economic aid for the Palestinians but will not address their aspirations to nationhood. King Salman of Saudi Arabia voiced his disapproval of any White House plan after Trump recognised the contested city of Jerusalem as the capital of Israel in December 2017.
"It was only a matter of time before the administration might try to push back against congressional upset with Saudi over Yemen and the Khashoggi murder to resume arms sales," said Aaron David Miller, a former State Department Middle East adviser and negotiator in Democratic and Republican administrations. "What better justification than a semi-manufactured national security war scare with Iran?"
In Washington, citing Khashoggi's killing, a bipartisan group of lawmakers has called for a prohibition of certain weapons sales to Riyadh and a blanket prohibition on the refuelling of Saudi-led coalition aircraft engaged in the civil war in Yemen.
In a winding and remarkable statement released last year after the killing of Khashoggi, Trump argued that punishing Saudi Arabia would jeopardise US$110 billion in military sales to Boeing, Lockheed Martin, Raytheon and other military contractors. "If we foolishly cancel these contracts, Russia and China would be the enormous beneficiaries — and very happy to acquire all of this newfound business," he said.
While the Pentagon and State Department have denied knowing whether U.S. bombs were used in Saudi Arabia's airstrikes in Yemen — which have struck weddings, mosques and funerals — a former senior State Department official said last year that the United States had access to records of every airstrike since the early days of the war.
Written by: Edward Wong, Catie Edmondson and Eric Schmitt
Photographs by: Tyler Hicks and Erin Schaff
© 2019 THE NEW YORK TIMES
Six people have now died in a suspected mass methanol poisoning event.