Pagers at the Gold Apollo factory in Taipei. The Taiwanese company claims that another manufacturer, using Gold Apollo's brand as part of a licensing deal, had made the batch of pagers which had explosive material concealed inside. Photo / Lam Yik Fei, The New York Times
Pagers at the Gold Apollo factory in Taipei. The Taiwanese company claims that another manufacturer, using Gold Apollo's brand as part of a licensing deal, had made the batch of pagers which had explosive material concealed inside. Photo / Lam Yik Fei, The New York Times
The company, Gold Apollo, said it had not manufactured the devices, pointing to another company that it said was licensed to use its brand.
Gold Apollo, a Taiwanese company that American and other officials named as the supplier of pagers used in attacks in Lebanon that killed atleast 11 people, sought Wednesday to distance itself from the devices.
US and other officials briefed on the attack had said that Israel had inserted explosive material into a shipment of pagers from Gold Apollo, in an apparently co-ordinated operation aimed at Hezbollah.
Gold Apollo denied that it had made the pagers, pointing instead at another manufacturer that it said had made that model of pager, using Gold Apollo’s brand, as part of a licensing deal.
Explosive material that had been concealed inside a batch of the pagers detonated after they received a signal. Around 2700 people were also injured by the attack.
But at Gold Apollo’s office on the outskirts of Taipei on Wednesday, Hsu Ching-Kuang, the company’s founder and president, said the pagers were made by another company. Gold Apollo later identified that company as BAC Consulting, a firm it described as having an address in Budapest, Hungary.
The explosions hit locations in several Hezbollah strongholds around Lebanon. Photo / Anwar Amro, AFP
Hsu said he had agreed about three years ago to let BAC sell its own products using the Gold Apollo brand, which he said had a good reputation in the niche market.
“That product isn’t ours. They just stick on our company brand,” Hsu told journalists, adding that in return his company received a share of the profits.
“We only provide brand trademark authorisation and have no involvement in the design or manufacturing of this product,” Gold Apollo said in a written statement. Even so, the Gold Apollo website displayed a picture of the pager model until the webpage was taken down Wednesday.
Some of the officials briefed on the operation had said the pagers, which Hezbollah had ordered, had been tampered with before they reached Lebanon, and that most were Gold Apollo’s AR924 model, though three other Gold Apollo models were also included in the shipment.
In a separate statement, Gold Apollo said the AR924 model was produced and sold by BAC, with which it had a “long-term partnership”. “Our company only provides the brand trademark authorisation and is not involved in the design or manufacturing of this product,” the company said.
Efforts to contact BAC and verify Gold Apollo’s account were not immediately successful.
Cristiana Bársony-Arcidiacono, who lists herself as the CEO of BAC Consulting on LinkedIn, did not immediately respond to messages. “I don’t make the pagers,” she told NBC News. “I am just the intermediate.”
A top Hungarian official also tried to distance the country from the explosions. “The company in question is a trading intermediary, with no manufacturing or operational site in Hungary,” Zoltan Kovacs, Hungary’s secretary for international communication, said in a post on social media. He added, “The referenced devices have never been in Hungary.”
Workers at the Gold Apollo factory in Taipei, Taiwan. Photo / Lam Yik Fei, The New York Times
Tracing how and when the pagers were packed with explosive material could be complicated. Taiwan’s sprawling consumer electronics industry is a complex supply chain of brands, manufacturers and agents.
Taiwan’s Ministry of Economic Affairs, which oversees trade, said that its records showed “no direct exports to Lebanon” of such pagers from Gold Apollo. The company’s pagers were mainly exported to Europe and North America, the ministry said. The company reviewed news reports and photographs and judged that the pagers had been modified only after being exported from Taiwan, the ministry said. The New York Times could not independently verify the assessment.
Hsu said that he had a long-standing relationship with BAC before they struck the brand licensing deal. Looking back, he said, there was one “odd” incident with BAC, when a local Taiwanese bank had delayed a bank transfer from the company because the local bank had suspicions about it. Hsu said the transfer might have come from a bank in the Middle East. He did not say which country.
