"It came up on our left-hand side (rapidly veered) to the north, we saw a bright light and it just disappeared at a very high speed . . . we were just wondering," the pilot said, according to the newspaper and audio of the interaction posted on the Internet.
"We didn't think it was a likely collision course . . . (just wondering) what it could be."
Also wondering were pilots flying nearby, who saw the same, well, whatever it was.
A Virgin Airlines pilot of Flight VS76 from Orlando to Manchester said it was not something, but somethings: "Multiple objects following the same sort of trajectory - very bright from where we were."
The Irish Aviation Authority said the reports will be "investigated under the normal confidential occurrence investigation process".
But for many people who read between the classified lines, there was no need. We already know the Truth.
This is normally the point at which chortling naysayers would shout their disbelief. After all, for decades the public has been told that aliens don't actually exist and that people who believed otherwise were crackpots in tinfoil hats.
But in an admission straight out of a B movie, the Pentagon recently confirmed that there was a US$22 million government programme to collect and analyse "anomalous aerospace threats" - government speak for UFOs.
And Area 51, the secret base in Nevada whose existence had been denied by the government for decades - has actually existed for decades, the US Government admitted. It was a test strip for a CIA spy plane and other classified aircraft, according to a CIA history declassified in 2013. And because the government had a giant secret test base in the Nevada desert, it used the area for all kinds of secret testing: putting the A-12 aircraft and the angular F-117 stealth ground attack jet through their paces.
So who needs a tinfoil hat now? The admission lent a patina of viability to a century of bizarre, unexplained phenomena.
But what of the bright lights over the Atlantic seen by not one but two airline crews responsible for the health and well-being of hundreds of passengers?
Aircraft experts told the Irish Examiner that the lights were probably meteorites entering Earth at a low angle. The high speeds were due to acceleration caused by Earth's gravity. The bright lights were probably the result of friction as the celestial bodies pierced Earth's atmosphere.
Sure. We believe you.