The opinion piece headed "US democracy trumps all as a dysfunctional disgrace" by Australian academic Mark Triffitt that appeared in the Herald earlier this week resembled Sherlock Holmes' curious incident of the dog in the night-time in that there was silence when there shouldn't have been.
Just as the dog didn't bark when it should have, Triffitt's piece didn't contain a single reference to Democrats and Republicans or left and right. The clear inference, therefore, is that the depressing state of US politics is the fault of both sides and dysfunction is systemic.
Take this for example: "Nearly every leading 2016 presidential candidate is uttering outright lies, mostly false statements or half truths at least half the time they open their mouths." There's a word missing between "2016" and "presidential" and that word is "Republican." As I pointed out in this space on December 4, the Pulitzer Prize-winning fact-checking organisation PolitiFact found the lies of Republican candidates to be of a vastly different order of frequency and magnitude than those of Democrats Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders.
While the Democrats are still recognisably the party of Franklin Roosevelt, John Kennedy and Bill Clinton, the Republican Party has been swept off its mooring. Research shows the percentage of non-centrist Republicans in Congress has gone from 10 per cent during the Gerald Ford presidency (1974-77) to almost 90 per cent, while the Democrats' ratio has remained the same. Almost half the Republicans in the House of Representatives were found to be more extreme than the most extreme Democrat.
American democracy is dysfunctional because Republicans have largely abandoned consensus politics. Democracy is essentially the means by which society manages political division. It depends on tolerance, moderation, an acceptance that roughly half the citizenry doesn't share your perspective and priorities. Hence democracy and ideology are fundamentally incompatible.