A baffling alert. A race to the wrong building. Notre-Dame still stands only because firefighters decided to risk everything, a New York Times investigation has found.
The employee monitoring the smoke alarm panel at Notre Dame Cathedral was just three days on the job when the red warning light flashed on the evening of April 15: "Feu." Fire.
It was 6:18 on a Monday, the week before Easter. The Reverend Jean-Pierre Caveau was celebrating Mass before hundreds of worshippers and visitors, and the employee radioed a church guard who was standing just a few feet from the altar.
Go check for fire, the guard was told. He did and found nothing.
It took nearly 30 minutes before they realised their mistake: The guard had gone to the wrong building. The fire was in the attic of the cathedral, the famed latticework of ancient timbers known as "the forest."
The miscommunication, uncovered in interviews with church officials and managers of the fire security company, Elytis, has set off a bitter round of finger-pointing over who was responsible for allowing the fire to rage unchecked for so long. Who is to blame and how the fire started have not yet been determined and are at the heart of an investigation by French authorities that will continue for months.
But the damage is done. What happened over four hours that night changed Paris. The cathedral — a soaring medieval structure that has captured the hearts of believers and nonbelievers alike for 850 years — was ravaged.
Today, three jagged openings mar Notre Dame's vaulted ceiling, the stone of the structure is precarious, and the roof is gone. Some 150 workers remain busy recovering the stones, shoring up the building, and protecting it from the elements with two giant tarps.
Some of what went wrong that night has been reported in the French news media, including Le Monde and Le Canard Enchaîné. Now, The New York Times conducted scores of interviews and reviewed hundreds of documents to reconstruct the missteps — and the battle that saved Notre Dame in the first four critical hours after the blaze began.
What became clear is just how close the cathedral came to collapsing.
The first hour was defined by that initial, critical mistake: the failure to identify the location of the fire, and by the delay that followed.
The second hour was dominated by a sense of helplessness. As people raced to the building, waves of shock and mourning for one of the world's most beloved and recognisable buildings, amplified over social media, rippled in real time across the globe.
That Notre Dame still stands is due solely to the enormous risks taken by firefighters in those third and fourth hours.
Disadvantaged by their late start, firefighters would rush up the 300 steps to the burning attic and then be forced to retreat. Finally, a small group of firefighters was sent directly into the flames, as a last, desperate effort to save the cathedral.
"There was a feeling that there was something bigger than life at stake," said Ariel Weil, mayor of the city's 4th Arrondissement, home to the cathedral, "and that Notre Dame could be lost."
Precious time lost
Paris has endured so much in recent years, from terrorist attacks to the recent violent demonstrations by Yellow Vest protesters. But to many Parisians, the sight of Notre Dame in flames was unendurable.
"For Parisians, Notre Dame is Notre Dame," said its rector, Monsignor Patrick Chauvet, who watched in tears that night as firefighters struggled to tame the blaze. "They couldn't think for one second that this could happen."
The fire warning system at Notre Dame took dozens of experts six years to put together, and in the end involved thousands of pages of diagrams, maps, spreadsheets and contracts, according to archival documents found in a suburban Paris library by The Times.
The result was a system so arcane that when it was called upon to do the one thing that mattered — warn "fire!" and say where — it produced instead a nearly indecipherable message.
It made a calamity almost inevitable, fire experts consulted by The Times said.
"The only thing that surprised me is that this disaster didn't happen sooner," said Albert Simeoni, an expert born and trained in France, but now head of fire protection engineering at Worcester Polytechnic Institute in Massachusetts.
The ponderous response plan, for example, underestimated the speed at which a fire would spread in Notre Dame's attic, where no sprinklers or fire walls had been added to preserve the architecture.
The plan's flaws may have been compounded by the inexperience of the security employee, who had been working at Notre Dame just three days when the fire broke out.
Stationed since 7am within the pale-green walls of the tiny presbytery room, he was supposed to have been relieved after working an eight-hour shift. His replacement was absent, so he was on the second leg of a double shift.
The control panel he monitored was connected to an elaborate system consisting of tubes with tiny holes that ran throughout the cathedral complex. At one end of each tube was what is called an "aspirating" detector — a highly sensitive device that draws in air to detect any smoke.
The message that scrolled across the monitor was far more complicated than the mere word "Feu."
First it gave a shorthand description of a zone — the cathedral complex was divided into four — that read "Attic Nave Sacristy."
That was followed by a long string of letters and numbers — ZDA-110-3-15-1 — code for a specific smoke detector among more than 160 detectors and manual alarms in the complex.
Finally, came the important part: "aspirating framework" — indicating an aspirating detector in the cathedral's attic, which was also known as the framework.
It remains unclear just how much of that entire alert the employee understood or conveyed to the guard — and whether the critical part of it was relayed at all, though Elytis insists it was.
By the time it was sorted out, the flames were already running wild, too high to be controlled by a fire extinguisher.
Finally, the guard radioed the fire security employee to call the fire department. It was 6:48, 30 minutes after the first red signal lit up the word "Feu."
All the sensitive technology at the heart of system had been undone by a cascade of oversights and erroneous assumptions built into the planning, said Glenn Corbett, an associate professor of fire science at John Jay College of Criminal Justice in New York City.
"You have a system that is known for its ability to detect very small quantities of smoke," Corbett said. "Yet the whole outcome of it is this clumsy human response. You can spend a lot to detect a fire, but it all goes down the drain when you don't move on it."
A global spectacle
If it took more than half an hour to call the fire department, it took just minutes once smoke appeared for the images to begin circulating around the world on social media.
"I think Notre-Dame is burning," someone posted on a Twitter video at 6:52pm. Within just a few minutes, the smoke, blowing west with the wind, was so thick it started to obscure the towers.
Une fumée sombre s'échappe de Notre Dame de Paris. Ça craint. @radionotredame @dioceseparis pic.twitter.com/QpLxuJVVce
— François Berdougo (@FBerdougo) April 15, 2019
— Hash Miser (@H_Miser) April 15, 2019
The moment the tower of Notre Dame fell. @cnnbrk @BBCWorld @ANCALERTS @rapplerdotcom pic.twitter.com/0UK0QbQUwr
— Marga Abejo-Momper (@faiyah) April 15, 2019
Minutes earlier, at 6:44, Elaine Leavenworth, a tourist from Chicago, had taken a picture of the facade against a clear blue sky. By the time she took a short walk across Pont Saint-Michel, she smelled smoke. She looked back to see the towers engulfed in smoke and took another shot.
"Frightening how quickly it changed," Leavenworth posted on Twitter at 6:55pm, along with the two photos.
Chauvet, the rector, had been chatting just a couple of hundred yards from the cathedral with shopkeepers, when suddenly one of them pointed up and exclaimed: "Look, there is smoke coming out!"
A sinking feeling took hold. "I said to myself: 'It's the forest that's caught fire,'" Chauvet recalled, referring to the cathedral's attic.
He pulled out his cellphone and warned his staff. They said the fire department had been called but had yet to arrive.
"I was incapable of doing anything," Chauvet said. "I couldn't say anything. I watched the cathedral burn."
Weil, the mayor of the 4th Arrondissement, was just leaving a long meeting at the nearby Hôtel de Ville, the city hall, when he saw the smoke and ran toward Notre Dame.
He called the mayor of Paris, Anne Hidalgo, and she rushed to meet him. When they reached the plaza, tears were streaming down Chauvet's face. Ashes and fiery flakes drifted through the air.
"It was like an end-of-the-world atmosphere," Weil said.
On the plaza, the gathering crowd was stunned, immobilised.
"I cried because you are helpless to do anything," Chauvet said. "You wait for the firefighters."
A firefighter's view
By the time Master Cpl. Myriam Chudzinski arrived, a few minutes before 7pm, Notre Dame was surrounded by hundreds of horrified bystanders. The fire already glowed through the roof.
Chudzinski, 27, had wanted to be a firefighter since she was a little girl. Now she was staring speechless at a kind of blaze she had never encountered.
Her truck stopped on the Rue du Cloître-Notre-Dame, a narrow street that runs on one side of the cathedral. The building was so gigantic, she could not see where the fire was spreading anymore.
"We were so small that it was hard to get a proper idea from the bottom of the cathedral," she said. "But it might have been better like that."
Better not to know the danger she was walking into.
Chudzinski's team was one of the first to arrive and headed to the attic. They immediately plugged their hoses into the cathedral's dry risers, empty vertical pipes that would allow them to pump water up to the flames.
Bearing 55 pounds of gear and a breathing pipe on her shoulder, she climbed the dark staircase in the transept on the cathedral's north side.
She knew the structure well, having drilled at Notre Dame in the fall. As she climbed, she recalled that the attic had no firewalls to prevent the spread of a blaze — they had been rejected to preserve the web of historic wooden beams.
With such intense flames, she realised, the attic would be a tinderbox.
Aside from the drill, Chudzinski had visited the cathedral once a few years ago, marvelling at its vastness.
"It was so peaceful, so quiet," she said. "But that night, it was more like hell."
Once at the top, Chudzinski and her team stopped on a cornice outside the attic as she took the lead dousing the flames, about 15 feet away.
Her colleague holding the hose behind her could see that the flames were being pushed by a brisk wind toward the cathedral's northern tower. The fire was starting to surround them, threatening to trap them outside, in the middle of the inferno. They retreated inside, toward the attic.
There was no wind there. But the air was so hot, so barely breathable, that for the first time that night, Chudzinski plugged in her breathing apparatus. Her thirst was terrible.
In the attic, the flames advanced as an unstoppable wall. They covered countless beams already and nibbled up the floor. Pieces of wood frayed and fell from the timbers one by one.
About 7:50, almost an hour into the fight, a deafening blast engulfed her, like "a giant bulldozer dropping dozens of stones into a dumpster."
Touch and go
President Emmanuel Macron had arrived, along with Prime Minister Édouard Phillippe and other top officials, to survey the damage. It was near 8:30pm.
A group of about 20 officials, including Hidalgo, Weil and Chauvet, convened across the plaza at police headquarters for a briefing by Gen. Jean-Claude Gallet, head of the Paris fire brigade.
Clad in firefighting gear, dripping with water, Gallet, 54, had served in Afghanistan and specialised in crisis management. He entered the conference room and gave them the bad news.
Scenes from a Firefighter's Notebook
For all the high-tech gear available to big-city fire departments, investigators still see value in old-school tools. These drawings were made by a French firefighter and professional sketch artist, Laurent Clerjeau, as the cathedral burned, and in the days afterward. They show how the flames spread, and record what firefighters did to try to contain them.
Image 1 of 8: One of a series of drawings made by a French firefighter and professional sketch artist, Laurent Clerjeau, as the Cathedral of Notre Dame burned, and in the days afterward. Image / Via The New York Times
The attic could no longer be saved. He had decided to let it go. He would have his brigades throw all their energy into saving the towers, focusing on the northern one, already on fire.
"He came in and told us, 'In 20 minutes, I'll know if we've lost it,'" Weil said. "The air was so thick. But we knew what he meant: He meant Notre Dame could collapse."
"At that point," Weil said, "it was clear that some firefighters were going to go into the cathedral without knowing if they would come back out."
Chauvet wept. The prime minister circled his thumbs nervously.
Macron remained silent, but appeared to give tacit approval to Gallet's decision.
Out on the square, a temporary command post had been set up. There, Gallet's deputy, Gen. Jean-Marie Gontier, was managing the firefighters on the front lines.
He gathered them around him to prepare the second stage of the battle. A slippery carpet of ashes covered the stones underfoot in black and gray.
The situation looked grim. Whiteboards displayed sketches of the fire's progress. Police drone footage showed the cathedral's roof as a fiery cross illuminating the night sky. At the centre was a gaping hole where the spire had stood for more than 160 years.
Thick smoke was billowing from the wooden frame of the northern tower. Thumb-size embers flew like glittering hornets and pierced some hoses. One of the dry risers needed to get water to the top of the cathedral was leaking, lowering the water pressure.
Now, all that time lost because the firefighters had been called late became critical. Gontier compared it to a footrace.
"It's like starting a 400 metres, several dozen meters behind," he said.
Gabriel Plus, the Paris fire brigade spokesman, said, "We needed to make decisions, quickly."
At the command post, Master Sgt. Rémi Lemaire, 39, suggested that they could go up the stairs in the southern tower, where he had been earlier in the fight.
They could carry up two additional hoses, he said, that could be plugged directly into a fire truck. That would give the team more water pressure than the leaking riser could muster. And then from there, the firefighters could enter the blazing northern tower.
It was a high-risk strategy. But Gontier agreed.
No way out
Lemaire had already seen the perils that the northern tower held earlier that evening. In the time it took to decide on the new plan, things only got worse.
"We were at first reluctant to go because we weren't sure we'd have an escape route," he said.
A group of firefighters from a neighbouring suburb refused to go, but another team said it would do it.
They broke a gate, and as they went inside the northern tower, found parts of a wall and the floor on fire. They climbed a set of stairs to the height of the bells. From there, they could douse the flames.
One firefighter almost fell through the cracking steps — but by 9:45, they had the flames under control.
Gontier went up on the balcony of Notre Dame to inspect the situation.
"She is saved," he declared as he descended.
By 11, Gallet told officials they were confident that the fire in the towers would be brought under control. Around 11:30, Macron addressed the nation live on television from in front of the cathedral.
"The worst was avoided, even though the battle is not yet over," he said. Then he made a pledge: "We will rebuild this cathedral together."
The finger-pointing
Over the past three months, investigators have conducted some 100 interviews and sifted the rubble, looking for clues to what started the fire.
They have focused on the possibility of a short-circuit in the electrified bells of the spire, or in the elevators that had been set up on the scaffolding to help workers carry out renovations. They are also considering cigarette butts, which were found on the scaffolding, apparently left by workers.
"We're not ruling out any scenario, we just know it wasn't criminal," said a Paris police official, speaking on the condition of the anonymity because the investigation is still underway.
The miscommunication that allowed the fire to rage unchecked for so long is now the source of a bitter dispute over who is responsible.
Church officials say that the employee for Elytis, the fire security company, never mentioned the framework of the cathedral's roof.
"Several of them had a walkie-talkie and all heard 'Attic Nave Sacristy,'" said André Finot, a spokesman for Notre Dame. "That's all."
Chauvet, Notre Dame's rector, has refused to make the employees available independently for interviews, citing the investigation.
"Some might lose their jobs,'' he said. "I asked them not to talk."
Arnaud Demaret, chief executive officer of Elytis, said his employee was still in shock. The company received two death threats over the telephone in the days after the fire, he said.
But he insisted that his employee had communicated the fire's location properly.
"There is only one wooden framework," Demaret said in an interview. "It's in the attic."
"Had the church employee gone up to the attic right after my employee alerted him," he said, "he would have seen the smoke."
A lesson in fragility
After the fire was brought under control, Lemaire and his colleagues stayed up on the roof to put out the flames there and protect the southern tower, where three small fires had started.
Chudzinski spent the rest of the night helping make space for other fire trucks and securing the area. Then she went back to her station. The city was quiet.
She remembered her retreat, and the drone footage showing the cathedral from above as a flaming cross. Only then, when she was no longer absorbed in fighting the fire, did she fully comprehend the scope of the response.
"I didn't know how huge the teamwork had been," she said.
Miraculously, no one was killed.
Three days later, she and Lemaire were among the hundreds of firefighters and police officers honoured by Macron at the Élysée Palace.
Countless Parisians stopped by the city's fire stations to donate food and small gifts and express their thanks. Notes came from around the world.
"These people were heroes," Weil said.
Still, more than a few wondered why at a time when citizens were taking to the streets protesting inequality and economic hardship, when so many were dying in distant wars and on migrant boats sailing for Europe, should Notre Dame matter.
But Notre Dame was more than a building. It rests on Île de la Cité, the island in the middle of the Seine River where Paris was born. Made and remade over the centuries, it remains a focal point of French culture that has responded to the demands of each age it has passed through.
And in the present moment, it represented an unbreakable link with what, for many French, is the essence of their increasingly fragile nationhood.
"Notre Dame is good and old: Perhaps we'll even see her bury Paris, whose birth she witnessed," the poet Gérard de Nerval once said.
That was back in the 19th century.
That sense of the cathedral as a living, wounded entity has only intensified since the fire.
"First off, this is all about our fragility," Chauvet, the rector, said on reflection. "We are as nothing. The fragility of man, in respect to God. We are nothing but — creatures."
Written by: Elian Peltier, James Glanz, Mika Gröndahl, Weiyi Cai, Adam Nossiter and Liz Aldermani
Photographs by: Dmitry Kotyukov
© 2019 THE NEW YORK TIMES
