Ceres, the largest object in the asteroid belt between Mars and Jupiter, should be riddled with craters.
But when Nasa's Dawn spacecraft started orbiting the dwarf planet last year, scientists were surprised to find it was relatively smooth.
In a study published yesterday in Nature Communications, researchers conclude that something mysterious must have erased the marks.
Given the pockmarked appearance of most asteroid belt objects - including Vesta, the asteroid that Dawn visited before arriving at Ceres - scientists expected many large craters to pepper their planetary target.
"Ceres is thought to have formed at the dawn of the solar system, some one to ten million years or so after the onset of formation," lead researcher Simone Marchi at Southwest Research Institute told the Guardian.