The FBI isn't buying the heavenly intervention angle.
The organisation issued a wanted poster for Jeffs, who is "thought to be a leader in the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints".
The church is not affiliated with the Mormon church - they separated decades ago. FLDS members practice polygamy and have been accused of taking wives who are too young to give consent.
Agents say Jeffs is most likely hiding out in one of the safe houses belonging to the church, and that he "should be considered armed and dangerous".
The FBI is offering US$50,000 for information that leads to Jeffs's arrest. No person or divine entity has come forward to claim the reward since it was announced yesterday.
The case is more than just an outlandish excuse for a defendant on the lam. The controversial church's existence may hinge on whether Lyle Jeffs is free or not.
The Southern Poverty Law Centre has called the FLDS "a white supremacist, homophobic, anti-government, totalitarian cult" that has taken over small towns on the Utah-Arizona border. In a civil rights trial, prosecutors argued that two of those communities discriminate against people who are not church members, according to the Post.
As Melissa Etehad wrote in the Post, the FLDS "came under national scrutiny when the church's self-described 'prophet,' Lyle Jeffs' brother Warren Jeffs, was sentenced to life in prison in 2011 for raping a child".
FLDS teaches that the biblical character Cain "was cursed with a black skin and he is the father of the Negro people," according to the SPLC, and that homosexuality is "the worst evil act you can do, next to murder".
In her book Stolen Innocence, former FLDS child bride Elissa Wall recounts that Jeffs taught everyone that "non-white people were the most evil of all outsiders".
Women followers of FLDS are often seen wearing prairie dresses to "cover their bodies from neck to ankles because their bodies are considered sacred temples that can't be exposed," according to ABC News. "They also never cut their hair because, according to their teachings, they will need it in heaven to wash men's feet as an anointing."
Most forms of entertainment are banned, and FLDS children are educated in home schools that have Warren Jeffs' face on the textbooks, wrote ABC News. At the north end of the FLDS community, there's a bunker-like network of tunnels 100m deep, designed to protect the church in case of a government raid.
Lyle Jeffs and 10 other FLDS members were arrested in February after being accused of diverting US$12 million in federal benefits, according to AP. The resulting vacuum of leadership could cause the church to implode, a former member said.
"If they are finally going to prosecute Lyle Jeffs and the leaders of the church, it will eventually bring the church down," Wallace Jeffs, a half-brother of Warren Jeffs who was expelled from FLDS, told the Salt Lake Tribune. "This pretty much cuts the head off the snake."
US District Judge Ted Stewart granted Lyle Jeffs supervised release June 9, over the objections of federal prosecutors, who warned that safe houses and a stream of FLDS cash made Lyle Jeffs a flight risk.
Two weeks after the judge signed the release order, by means heavenly or earthly, Lyle Jeffs was gone.
