"Some say that it is a miracle, while others are calling it a curse," journalist Lakhdar Souid told France 24.
There has been no official explanation for the lake's origins and while some geologists believe seismic activity may have caused groundwater to rise to the surface by disrupting the water table, others disagree.
According to local authorities, the volume of the pool could be one million cubic metres over more than one hectare, with a depth of between 10 and 18 metres.
No official ban on swimming has been put in place but Gafsa's Office of Public Safety warned Tunisians that the water may be contaminated or even radioactive.
"This lake is located in an area rich in phosphate deposits, which leave residue that is sometimes strongly radioactive," Mr Souid wrote in Tunisia Daily.
"So there is a real risk the water is contaminated and carcinogenic.
"In the first few days, the water was a crystal clear, turquoise blue. Now it is green and full of algae.
"This means it is not being replenished and is conducive to disease."
The Gafsa region of central Tunisia is home to the country's mining industry and phosphate was first discovered in 1886.
Tunisia is the world's fifth largest exporter of the chemical, used in agriculture and industry, and the Gafsa is home to one of the largest phosphate mines.
- Independent
