A bunch of plastic flowers is seen at the scene of a passenger bus accident in Mestre, near the city of Venice, Italy. Photo / AP
A bunch of plastic flowers is seen at the scene of a passenger bus accident in Mestre, near the city of Venice, Italy. Photo / AP
Venetian mainlanders stopped in dismay to pay respects to the 21 people, all but one foreign tourists, who were killed when an all-electric shuttle bus crashed through an overpass guardrail and fence, plunging more than 10 metres to the ground.
The raised road opposite a major train station is one of the boroughs of Mestre’s most frequently travelled, without second thoughts. But they now stopped to inspect the ageing guardrail and rusted fence — both of which the bus sliced through in a moment during Tuesday rush-hour traffic.
The bus was just a year old, and the 40-year-old driver with an untarnished record had just started his shift shuttling tourists from Piazzale Roma, at the edge of Venice’s famed canals, to a four-star campground on the mainland offering bargain accommodation. The driver, Alberto Rizzotto, was among the dead.
A video showed the city-owned bus disappear from the frame, as another larger bus travelling behind it continued along the overpass. Prosecutors ruled out contact with any other vehicle, and said the shuttle bus scraped against the guardrail for at least 50m before its fiery crash to a surface road.
The guardrail was bent to the pavement, and the fence was ripped open. The bus landed upside down, its front end crushed. Fire damage was visible.
“Inexplicable,” said Mayor Luigi Brugnaro, who has driven on the overpass hundreds of times. Regional Gov. Luca Zaia said the circumstances suggested the driver may have suddenly become ill.
Investigators hope that video from cameras inside the bus will reveal the reason for the crash.
Nine Ukrainians were among the dead tourists, along with four Romanians, three Germans, two Portuguese, one Croat and one South African.
The injured included at least four Ukrainians, part of a larger group that included a 3-year-old girl who suffered serious burns, as well as visitors from Spain, Austria, France, Croatia and Germany. Nine were being treated in intensive care for trauma, including burns and fractures. Survivors also included a young Austrian brother and sister.
Damaged guardrails are seen at the scene of a passenger bus accident in Mestre, near the city of Venice, Italy. Photo / AP
The tourists are all believed to have stayed at the Hu Venezia Camping in Town, just a 15-minute drive from the shuttle bus’ pickup point at Piazzale Roma, at the edge of Venice’s famed canals linked to the mainland by a bridge.
Family members of the dead and survivors were trickling into Venice from around Europe on Wednesday. The Veneto region declared three days of mourning, and flags were flown at half-staff at government buildings.
Experts said the fact that the bus was electric contributed to the massive fire and made rescue operations more difficult.
“I won’t forget what I saw for the rest of my life,” said Brugnaro. “Seeing all those people crammed inside a bus, down there, is something you can’t describe.”
Venice is in the process of replacing its buses with electric vehicles. They were introduced on the city’s Lido island several years ago, with a small percentage added to the fleet in Mestre last year.
Italian firefighters work at the scene of a passenger bus accident in Mestre, near Venice, Italy. Photo / AP
Brugnaro said the crash didn’t give him reason to pause the city’s plan to upgrade city transportation vehicles to less-polluting electric buses, even if it needs to be determined what role the battery might have played in the ensuing blaze.
That the bus drove off an overpass “has nothing to do with the fact that it is electric”, the mayor said.
The bus was made by China-based Yutong Group Co., which describes itself as a large-scale industrial company specialising in buses.
On its website, Yutong shows newer models with multiple electronic safety systems including a lane departure warning, automatic emergency braking, collision warning and collision mitigation control. It wasn’t clear from photographs at the scene which of the company’s models were involved.
The website says the buses have buffer spaces for high-voltage electrical components at the front and rear. It also says the buses have enhanced anti-crash structures.
“Fully spatial and thermal isolation between battery cabin and passenger compartment poses no threat to passengers, even if the batteries catch fire,” the website says.
Two long-time foreign residents of Italy who work at the Fincantieri shipyard near the crash site were among the first to respond. Godstime Erheneden, 30, of Nigeria and Boubacar Touré, 27 of Gambia, were preparing dinner in a company apartment overlooking the busy road when they heard the crash and ran outside.
Erheneden was among the first to enter the bus.
“When we went in, we saw the driver right away. He was dead. I carried a woman out on my shoulders, then a man,” Erheneden told the Venice daily Il Gazzettino.
“The woman was screaming, ‘my daughter, my daughter,’ and I went back in. I saw this girl who must have been 2 years old,” he said, reminded of his own son about the same age. “It was terrible. I don’t know if she survived. I thought she was alive but when the rescuers arrived, they took her away immediately.”
