The report says “severe mistakes and errors” were made in the Israeli army's response as Hamas overran the Kibbutz Beeri community. Photo / Washington Post
The report says “severe mistakes and errors” were made in the Israeli army's response as Hamas overran the Kibbutz Beeri community. Photo / Washington Post
The report says “severe mistakes and errors” were made in the army response as Hamas overran the community. The army was underprepared, it said, and did not always prioritise civilian lives. The report detailed how in the afternoon, Israel Defence Forces units waited nearby even as residents were killed.
“From the afternoon hours onwards, forces were waiting outside the kibbutz while the massacre continued inside,” it said. “The IDF did not fulfil its mission to defend the residents in the most grave manner and failed in its mission.”
Military officials presented the findings to the surviving members of the community at the Dead Sea resort they now call home. A total of 101 people died in Beeri — one-tenth of the population — as Hamas fighters from Gaza broke through Israel’s high-tech border fence and took military units by surprise.
Dozens more were taken hostage, 11 of whom have yet to be released.
Up and down the border, outgunned community guards and residents were left fighting virtually alone.
“We failed to protect the kibbutz,” Rear Admiral Daniel Hagari, an IDF spokesman, conceded as he spoke to residents, according to Israeli press reports. He noted the IDF probe fell short of a wider independent commission of inquiry that he said “should be established”.
Nine months after the attack, there is increasing public pressure for accountability over the historic collapse in security that enabled Hamas-led militants to rampage into Israeli communities bordering the Gaza Strip. So far, only a smattering of security leaders have resigned, and the prospect of culpability among the political echelons appears even more distant.
A total of 101 people died in Beeri — one-tenth of the population — as Hamas fighters from Gaza broke through Israel’s high-tech border fence and took military units by surprise. Photo / Washington Post
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has repeatedly rejected establishing an independent commission while Israel is at war. The IDF’s internal investigations are unlikely to go far in assuaging public demands, and there is deep scepticism over the army’s ability to investigate itself.
“It’s taken with a grain of salt,” Tamar Hermann, a senior research fellow at the Israel Democracy Institute, said of the probe. “People expect some kind of official commission of inquiry composed of people who were not involved in any way.”
While the IDF has managed to partially repair its reputation in the eyes of many Israelis over the course of the Gaza war, anger still runs particularly deep in Beeri, she said.
“We should note that Kibbutz Beeri did not need the results of the investigation to feel the IDF’s failure every minute since 6.29am on that black Shabbat,” the kibbutz said in a written statement. “The army’s failure has been etched into our bodies and hearts for nine months now.”
The report detailed the chaos, confusion and bloodshed on the day of the attack, when about 340 militants entered the kibbutz, including about 100 Hamas special forces Nukhba fighters.
Smaller IDF units that arrived at the kibbutz in the morning were “hit” and “exited the community”, the report says. They positioned themselves at the gate and fought there as Hamas carried out kidnappings.
Meanwhile, members of the kibbutz’s security team held the line against the attack.
“For the first seven hours of combat, the kibbutz residents defended themselves; their actions and resourcefulness prevented the enemy from expanding the attack to additional neighbourhoods,” the report says.
The investigation did contribute to the understanding of the depth and complexity of the fighting in some parts of Beeri, the kibbutz statement says, but it added that the probe did not provide satisfactory answers to “critical questions”.
Those questions include why military forces gathered at the gate of the kibbutz for hours without entering, the root causes of the intelligence failure that permitted Hamas’ invasion, and whether the soldiers who arrived understood that their primary objective was to protect civilians.
A poll found a majority of Israelis think it is time for those responsible for the failings of October 7 to resign. Photo / Washington Post
Rami Gold, a 70-year-old member of Beeri’s security squad who attempted to hold off the militants that day, said the army’s investigation produced little new information.
“From my perspective,” he said, “what they said is, ‘We abandoned you’.”
Trust was broken, said Gold, who is among the few residents who have returned to live in Beeri.
“The army’s job is to make us trust it,” he said. “Right now, that’s not the case. I trust us.”
Days after the assault, the Washington Post observed rescue workers still clearing away the corpses from Beeri’s streets. Dead Hamas militants lay on the neatly clipped lawns and blood-smeared doorsteps of the modest homes of families who awoke to the rampage on a holiday morning.
The home of Pessi Cohen was left scorched and partially reduced to rubble. During their assault, Hamas militants had holed up in the house with 14 hostages.
Despite the presence of Israelis inside, Brigadier General Barak Hiram, who had been appointed to direct the fight in Beeri that afternoon, decided to target the building with tank shells. It was one of the most controversial acts of the morning by IDF forces.
The IDF concluded that the tank fire was carried out “professionally” with a joint decision made by commanders after a situational assessment “with the intent to apply pressure to the terrorists and save the civilians held hostage inside”.
The report did not specify whether Israel’s notorious Hannibal directive was in effect at the time. The directive instructs troops to do anything in their power to prevent Israelis from being kidnapped, even if that puts their lives at risk.
Haaretz newspaper reported this week the Hannibal directive was enacted on October 7, with an 11.22am order transmitted to troops that “not a single vehicle can return to Gaza”. It was one of several orders to use the directive over the course of the day, according to the newspaper.
The IDF has refused to say whether such an order was given. “Questions of this kind will be looked into at a later stage,” the IDF said on Thursday.
The attack raised many broad questions — and deep concerns — among Israelis about the country’s intelligence and defence capabilities. Information came to light in August that an attack was imminent, but warnings were dismissed, the Washington Post reported last year.
“You can’t just look at Beeri,” said Yossi Kuperwasser, former head of the research division in the IDF’s military intelligence agency. “You cannot separate it from everything else that happened on that terrible day.”
“For most people, the more important issues are the questions that pertain to the overall picture,” he said.
A majority of Israelis — some 58% of Jews and 81% of Arab citizens — think it is time for those responsible for the failings of October 7 to resign, according to an Israel Democracy Institute poll carried out in April. But public sentiment is increasingly polarised over the questions of who should be held responsible and the scope of an inquiry, said Hermann, of the Israel Democracy Institute. Left-wing and centrist Israelis were more likely to blame Netanyahu’s government, while right-wingers pointed the finger at the security establishment, she said.
The scope of any investigation remained unclear, she said, as does the body that would oversee it.
“There is no agreement on what should be done, and as time goes on more disagreement arises,” she said.
Meanwhile, Netanyahu has managed to keep his governing coalition together, shielding himself from any accountability at the ballot box. For Gold, accountability still feels illusive.
“The army is an arm of the state,” he said. “The state needs to introspect on what happened and take responsibility. I don’t see that responsibility has been taken.”
Here’s what else to know
An Israeli delegation returned home from Doha, Qatar, on Thursday for further consultations after participating in ceasefire talks, according to the Prime Minister’s office. The team will head to Cairo in the evening for further discussions. A statement issued by Hamas, however, said it had not been a party to the latest round: “We have yet to be informed by our brother mediators [Qatar and Egypt] anything regarding the negotiations for ceasefire or prisoner exchange.” The group also accused Israel of “procrastination” and aiming to thwart the negotiations.
An Israeli human rights group, B’Tselem, has condemned as “absolute madness” a directive by the Israeli military for all Palestinians to evacuate Gaza City. It added that “the international community must demand that Israel immediately stop the war”, which it said has sown destruction and killed masses of people. The sweeping IDF evacuation call was issued on Wednesday as the Israeli military designated the largest city in the Gaza Strip a “dangerous combat zone” and ramped up operations, sending thousands fleeing south.
A Gaza civil defence force spokesman said it had recovered 60 bodies from the rubble of Gaza City’s Shejaiya neighbourhood, among them women and children, after Israeli forces withdrew. Mahmoud Bassal described the area as “unfit for life” following an operation that lasted for days.
The United States is resuming a shipment of 500lb bombs to Israel. The arms shipment has been held up since May, when the Biden administration suspended delivery of two types of large, airdropped weapons amid concerns about the scale of civilian casualties in Gaza, US officials familiar with the matter told the Post. A supply of 1700, 500lb bombs will probably move forward, they said, speaking on condition of anonymity.
At least 38,345 people have been killed and 88,295 injured in Gaza since the war started, the Gaza Health Ministry says. It does not distinguish between civilians and combatants, but says most of the dead are women and children. Israel estimates 1200 people were killed in Hamas’ October 7 attack, including more than 300 soldiers, and it says 325 soldiers have been killed since the start of its military operations in Gaza.
