Tiny bits of plastic have infiltrated the deep sea's main food source and could alter the ocean's role in one of Earth's ancient cooling processes, scientists say.
As long as there has been marine life, there has been marine snow — a ceaseless drizzle of death and waste sinking from the surface into the depths of the sea.
The snow begins as motes, which aggregate into dense, flocculent flakes that gradually sink and drift past the mouths (and mouthlike apparatuses) of scavengers farther down. But even marine snow that is devoured will most likely be snowfall once more; a squid's guts are just a rest stop on this long passage to the deep.
Although the term may suggest wintry whites, marine snow is mostly brownish or greyish, comprising mostly dead things. For eons, the debris has contained the same things — flecks from plant and animal carcasses, faeces, mucus, dust, microbes, viruses — and transported the ocean's carbon to be stored on the seafloor. Increasingly, however, marine snowfall is being infiltrated by microplastics: fibres and fragments of polyamide, polyethylene and polyethylene terephthalate. And this fauxfall appears to be altering our planet's ancient cooling process.
Every year, tens of millions of tons of plastic enter Earth's oceans. Scientists initially assumed that the material was destined to float in garbage patches and gyres, but surface surveys have accounted for only about 1 per cent of the ocean's estimated plastic. A recent model found that 99.8 per cent of plastic that entered the ocean since 1950 had sunk below the first few hundred feet of the ocean. Scientists have found 10,000 times more microplastics on the seafloor than in contaminated surface waters.
Marine snow, one of the primary pathways connecting the surface and the deep, appears to be helping the plastics sink. And scientists have only begun to untangle how these materials interfere with deep-sea food webs and the ocean's natural carbon cycles.
"It's not just that marine snow transports plastics or aggregates with plastic," said Luisa Galgani, a researcher at Florida Atlantic University. "It's that they can help each other get to the deep ocean."
Marine snow-making
The sunlit surface of the sea blooms with phytoplankton, zooplankton, algae, bacteria and other minuscule life, all feeding on sunbeams or one another. As these microbes metabolise, some produce polysaccharides that can form a sticky gel that attracts the lifeless bodies of tiny organisms, small shreds of larger carcasses, shells from foraminifera and pteropods, sand and microplastics, which stick together to form larger flakes. "They are the glue that keeps together all the components of marine snow," Galgani said.
Marine snowflakes fall at different rates. Smaller ones have a more languid descent — "as slow as a meter a day," said Anela Choy, a biological oceanographer at Scripps Institution of Oceanography at the University of California, San Diego.
Bigger particles, such as dense faecal pellets, can sink quicker. "It just skyrockets to the bottom of the ocean," said Tracy Mincer, a researcher at Florida Atlantic University.
Plastic in the ocean is constantly being degraded; even something as big and buoyant as a milk jug will eventually shed and splinter into microplastics. These plastics develop biofilms of distinct microbial communities — the "plastisphere," said Linda Amaral-Zettler, a scientist at the Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research, who coined the term.
"We sort of think about plastic as being inert," Amaral-Zettler said. "Once it enters the environment, it's rapidly colonised by microbes."
Microplastics can host so many microbial hitchhikers that they counteract the natural buoyancy of the plastic, causing their raft to sink. But if the biofilms then degrade on the way down, the plastic could float back up, potentially leading to a yo-yoing purgatory of microplastics in the water column. Marine snow is anything but stable; as flakes free-fall into the abyss, they are constantly congealing and falling apart, rent by waves or predators.
"It's not as simple as: Everything's falling all the time," said Adam Porter, a marine ecologist at the University of Exeter in England. "It's a black box in the middle of the ocean, because we can't stay down there long enough to work out what's going on."
To explore how marine snow and plastics are distributed in the water column, Mincer has begun to sample deeper waters with a dishwashersize pump full of filters that dangles on a wire from a research boat. The filters are arranged from big mesh to small to filter out fish and plankton. Running these pumps for 10 hours at a stretch has revealed nylon fibres and other microplastics distributed throughout the water column below the South Atlantic subtropical gyre.
But even with a research boat and its expensive and unwieldy equipment, an individual piece of marine snow is not easily retrieved from deep water in the actual ocean. The pumps often disturb the snow and scatter faecal pellets. And the flakes alone offer little insight into how fast some snows are sinking, which is vital to understanding how long the plastics linger, yo-yo or sink in the water column before settling on the seafloor.
"Is it decades?" Mincer asked. "Is it hundreds of years? Then we can understand what we're in here for, and what kind of problem this really is."
Instant marine snow
To answer these questions, and work within a budget, some scientists have made and manipulated their own marine snow in the lab.
In Exeter, Porter collected buckets of seawater from a nearby estuary and loaded the water into continuously rolling bottles. He then sprinkled in microplastics, including polyethylene beads and polypropylene fibres. The constant churning, and a squirt of sticky hyaluronic acid, encouraged particles to collide and stick together into snow.
"We obviously don't have 300 metres of a tube to make it sink," Porter said. "By rolling it, what you're doing is you're creating a never-ending water column for the particles to fall through."
After the bottles rolled for three days, he pipetted out the snow and analysed the number of microplastics in each flake. His team found that every type of microplastic they tested aggregated into marine snow, and that microplastics such as polypropylene and polyethylene — normally too buoyant to sink on their own — readily sank once incorporated into marine snow. And all the marine snow contaminated with microplastics sank significantly faster than the natural marine snow.
Porter suggested that this potential change of the speed of the snow could have vast implications for how the ocean captures and stores carbon: Faster snowfalls could store more microplastics in the deep ocean, whereas slower snowfalls could make the plastic-laden particles more available to predators, potentially starving food webs deeper down. "The plastics are a diet pill for these animals," said Karin Kvale, a carbon cycle scientist at GNS Science in New Zealand.
In experiments in Crete, with funding from the European Union's Horizon 2020 research program, Galgani has tried mimicking marine snow on a larger scale. She dropped six mesocosms — huge bags that each contained nearly 800 gallons of seawater and re-created natural water movement — in a large pool. Under these conditions, marine snow formed. "In the field, you mostly make observations," Galgani said. "You have so little space and a limited system. In the mesocosm, you are manipulating a natural system."
Galgani mixed microplastics into three mesocosms in an attempt to "re-create a sea and maybe a future ocean where you can have a high concentration of plastic," she said. The mesocosms laden with microplastics produced not just more marine snow but also more organic carbon, as the plastics offered more surfaces for microbes to colonise. All this could seed the deep ocean with even more carbon and alter the ocean's biological pump, which helps regulate the climate.
"Of course, it's a very, very big picture," Galgani said. "But we have some signals that it can have an effect. Of course, it depends on how much plastic there is."
A plastic feast
To understand how microplastics might travel through deep-sea food webs, some scientists have turned to creatures for clues.
Every 24 hours, many species of marine organism embark on a synchronised migration up and down in the water column. "They do the equivalent of a marathon every day and night," Choy said.
Guilherme V.B. Ferreira, a researcher at the Rural Federal University of Pernambuco in Brazil, wondered: "Is it possible they are transporting the plastics up and down?"
Ferreira and Anne Justino, a doctoral student at the same university, collected vampire squids and midwater squids from a patch of the tropical Atlantic. They found a plethora of plastics in both species: mostly fibres, but also fragments and beads.
This made sense for midwater squids, which migrate toward the surface at night to feed on fish and copepods that eat microplastics directly. But vampire squids, which live in deeper waters with fewer microplastics, had even higher levels of plastic, as well as foam, in their stomachs. The researchers hypothesise that the vampire squids' primary diet of marine snow, especially meatier faecal pellets, may be funnelling plastics into their bellies.
"It's very concerning," Justino said. Ferreira said, "They are one of the most vulnerable species for this anthropogenic influence."
Justino has excavated fibres and beads from the digestive tracts of lanternfish, hatchetfish and other fish that migrate up and down in the mesopelagic, 198 metres to 1,000 metres down. Some microbial communities that settle on microplastics can bioluminesce, drawing in fish like a lure, said Mincer.
In the Monterey Bay Canyon, Choy wanted to understand if certain species of filter feeders were ingesting microplastics and transporting them into food webs in deeper water. "Marine snow is one of the major things that connects food webs across the ocean," she said.
Choy zeroed in on the giant larvacean Bathochordaeus stygius. The larvacean resembles a tiny tadpole and lives inside a palatial bubble of mucus that can reach up to 1 meter long. "It's worse than the grossest booger you've ever seen," Choy said. When their snot-houses become clogged from feeding, the larvaceans move out and the heavy bubbles sink. Choy found that these palaces of mucus are crowded with microplastics, which are funnelled to the deep along with all their carbon.
Giant larvaceans are found across the world's oceans, but Choy emphasised that her work was focused on the Monterey Bay Canyon, which belongs to a network of marine protected areas and is not representative of other, more polluted seas. "It's one deep bay on one coast of one country," Choy said. "Scale up and think about how vast the ocean is, especially the deep water."
Individual flakes of marine snow are small, but they add up. A model created by Kvale estimated that in 2010, the world's oceans produced 340 quadrillion aggregates of marine snow, which could transport as many as 463,000 tons of microplastics to the seafloor each year.
Scientists are still exploring exactly how this plastic snow is sinking, but they do know for sure, Porter said, that "everything eventually sinks in the ocean." Vampire squids will live and die and eventually become marine snow. But the microplastics that pass through them will remain, eventually settling on the seafloor in a stratigraphic layer that will mark our time on the planet long after humans are gone.
This article originally appeared in The New York Times.
Written by: Sabrina Imbler
© 2022 THE NEW YORK TIMES
