German police patrolling a park in Munich in March. Photo / Laetitia Vancon, The New York Times
In the postwar era, Germany fundamentally redesigned law enforcement to prevent past atrocities from ever repeating. Its approach may hold lessons for police reform everywhere.
When Inspector Martin Halweg was a young cadet, his class met a Holocaust survivor who had spent almost four years in a Berlin attic hiding from the Nazis — and from police officers like him.
"He described what it felt like running from the police, his fear, his absolute terror," said Halweg, who was only 16 when he started training in 1992.
Hearing this firsthand, he said, "changes you as a person and changes you as a police officer."
Visiting a former concentration camp is mandatory for every future police officer in Berlin. It is one of the ways in which policing was fundamentally overhauled in Germany after World War II. Cadets are taught in unsparing detail about the shameful legacy of policing under the Nazis — and how it informs the mission and institution of policing today.
"After the war, we had to start from scratch," said Klaus Weinhauer, a historian and police expert at Bielefeld University. "The country had to break with its history — and so did the police."
Germans have applied the lessons of their unique and horrid history to every aspect of their postwar democracy, not least to how they police their country. Those changes were partly imposed on Germany after the war and took decades to work their way through attitudes and institutions. But over time they have become pillars of German identity.
"You cannot compare the history of policing in America to the history of German policing under the Nazis," said Weinhauer, the historian.
But as Americans debate the need to rethink their own law enforcement in the wake of George Floyd's death under a white police officer's knee, Germany's experience may offer insight into what it takes to redesign institutions to prevent a painful past from repeating itself.
In Germany's case, the greatest preoccupation among the United States, its Allies and Germans themselves was that the country's police force never again be militarised, politicised and used as a cudgel by an authoritarian state.
So they set out to fashion a postwar force with decentralised responsibility to avoid letting a single agency become too powerful. The privacy of citizens was rigorously protected, and the police and military were strictly separated.
Even today, law enforcement in Germany is in the hands of the 16 states, not the national government, a system that can be cumbersome and imperfect, especially when dealing with modern-day challenges like terrorism.
But its safeguards have earned the respect of Germans. Police officers are required to pass a rigorous multiyear curriculum with history and Germany's liberal democratic constitution at its core. The bedrock of public safety in Germany is a strategy of communication and de escalation.
Under the Nazis, the police were a central tool of an all-powerful state. Police officers rounded up political enemies, deported Jews, guarded ghettos — and murdered. Some 30 police battalions helped kill more than 1 million people on the eastern front.
After World War II, the Western Allies had three priorities in West Germany, said Weinhauer, the historian: democratise, denazify and demilitarise.
The most notorious branch of the police under the Nazis was the Gestapo, the secret state police, which spied on citizens and also had the power to arrest. In the Communist East, the Stasi later also combined both powers into a terrifying instrument of oppression by the state.
Germany's democratic postwar constitution includes a strict separation of powers: The Office for the Protection of the Constitution, the country's domestic intelligence agency, cannot make arrests while the police have limited surveillance powers. The two are barred from exchanging information outside a dedicated counterterrorism forum.
"There is no such thing as an FBI in Germany," Weinhauer said.
But, he added, "It took many years until the police forces had learned to critically reflect on their own involvement in the Holocaust."
It wasn't until student protests in the 1960s and 1970s that German society began talking more openly about its Nazi past. In institutions like the police and the military, it took at least a decade longer.
In 1984, the Berlin police made a visit to the former Sachsenhausen concentration camp north of the German capital mandatory for cadets. By the time Halweg took his oath a decade later, the police rented out an entire movie theatre to show his graduating class Schindler's List.
"It made me very conscious of the oath that I swore on our constitution, to know what I stand for," Halweg said.
Opportunities to learn continue throughout a police career. The union for Germany's federal police organises two annual trips to Israel and its Holocaust memorial, Yad Vashem.
In Georgia, becoming a police officer takes as little as 11 weeks.
"That's completely unthinkable in Germany," Halweg said.
Most US police academies require only a high school diploma or associate degree and courses rarely run longer than the six months required in New York City.
Even the more elaborate training courses fall far short of Germany's minimum standards in terms of entry requirements, length and intensity.
"Before they even start, applicants have to pass personality and intelligence tests," said Margarete Koppers, Berlin's attorney general, who previously ran the Berlin police force.
Once accepted, training in Germany takes at least 2 1/2 years at an academy. Cadets are not just taught how to handle a gun but obliged to take classes in law, ethics and police history. When they graduate they are rewarded with high trust levels in society and civil servant status that guarantees decent pay and job security.
In another postwar innovation, German police officers do not handle minor infractions like parking tickets and noise ordinances, which are handled by uniformed but unarmed city employees.
"This was an idea of the Allies, they wanted to demilitarise and civilise police matters," said Ralf Poscher, director for the department of public law at the Max Planck Institute for the Study of Crime, Security and Law.
More than seven decades later, that early ambition of demilitarisation has morphed into a broad-based strategy of de escalation that has become the bedrock of modern German policing.
When Koppers, Berlin's attorney general, ran the Berlin police force, she recalled the number of officers who were left traumatised simply for having to draw their gun.
Gun ownership in Germany is low and shootings are rare.
"Violence is frowned upon in Germany," she said. "Even drawing a gun can lead to a police officer requesting psychological support."
The police here have what Germans call "a monopoly of force." Fewer guns on the streets translate to a lower threat faced by officers, and a lower number of people killed by police.
German police fatally shot 11 people and injured 34 while on duty in 2018, according to statistics compiled by the German Police Academy in Münster.
In the United States, with a population four times that of Germany, 1,098 people were killed by police in 2019, according to Mapping Police Violence. In Minnesota alone, where Floyd was killed, police fatally shot 13 people.
Despite the in-depth training, things can still go wrong. In July 2017, police used pepper spray and billy clubs against demonstrators who had targeted them with stones and bottles. More than 150 complaints were filed against the police for excessive use of force, although the majority of them were later dropped.
"It is a work in progress," said Poscher of the Max Planck Institute for the Study of Crime, Security and Law.
And sometimes the very remedies to past problems breed new ones.
By creating a system of policing that aims to protect privacy and prevent the institutional abuses of the Gestapo and the Stasi, German law enforcement agencies have found that some of the safeguards have undermined their ability to address challenges like terrorism — including far-right terrorism.
When a far-right terrorist network known as the National Socialist Underground killed nine immigrants over seven years in the early 2000s, the police assumed that it was other immigrants who had committed the murders even as the intelligence agency had infiltrated the group.
"It is a challenge," said Koppers, Berlin's attorney general. "How can we ensure that agencies communicate effectively despite the deliberate decentralisation of powers?"
And despite the active culture of remembrance, the German police are themselves not immune to racism. Dozens of police officers have been suspended on suspicion of links to neo-Nazi groups.
A number of migrants have died from excessive violence in police custody in recent decades. In the wake of mass protests against racism and police violence in the United States, German police have also come under increased criticism for racial profiling.
Burak Yilmaz, a police academy educator and social worker, said that since 2015, when hundreds of thousands of mostly Muslim migrants arrived in Germany, racism had become far more prevalent.
One lesson from German history, Yilmaz said, is that before institutions like the police can change a society's values must change.
"The police are a mirror of society," he said. "You cannot turn the police upside down and leave society as it is."
Written by: Katrin Bennhold and Melissa Eddy
Photographs by: Laetitia Vancon
© 2020 THE NEW YORK TIMES
The Boeing 777 aircraft disappeared from radar screens carrying 239 people in 2014.