• Dorothy Finlay NZRN, BSN, M St John (2002) lived In Jerusalem and Gaza between the years 1985-2013 as a nurse working with Palestinians in Jerusalem, Gaza and Bethlehem is also an Arabic speaker.
I can understand Dr Robin Briant's anger at the destruction of Palestinian buildings during the time of her service with Medecins sans Frontieres in Jenin and Gaza. I too would be very upset if I did not understand the situation in the Palestinian and Gaza authority areas during the years 2003-2004 when Dr Briant describes her experience.
However, the situation now is very different, and certainly less violent, from when Dr Briant was there 13 years ago. In the years 2001-2004 over 1000 Israelis were killed in terrorist attacks.
Exaggeration of what was going on at that time was common. Another New Zealander, made a film, toured here, which included the allegation of the "Jenin massacre" of 500 or more civilians. All the later, rigorous investigations (by the UN, Human Rights Watch etc) came up with the number of Palestinian deaths as about 50, of whom half were fighters.
During those years where the main destructive force was the suicide bomber, Israel did use the destruction of homes belonging to the suicide bombers and their families as a non-lethal way to punish the bombers' families. The bombs where detonated at checkpoints aiming to kill as many Israeli soldiers as possible.