Please don't call it our Dien Bien Phu," said Lieutenant Colonel Simon Winkworth, of Britain's Royal Engineers, as we gazed out on to a desolate expanse of scrub and sand on which he was going to build Camp Bastion.
There were reasons for optimism on that February day, eight years ago, that Britain's Helmand force would not suffer the same fate as the French in Vietnam when a prolonged siege of that base effectively brought their occupation of Vietnam to an end.
The British would not underestimate the enemy as the French had done, we were assured. And John Reid, the then Defence Secretary, stated, when the mission was announced by Tony Blair's Government, that it would last no more than two years and end, he hoped, "without a shot being fired" in anger.
Yesterday, the Union flag was lowered for the last time in Camp Bastion, bringing an end to Britain's Afghan war after 13 years, three weeks and five days.