Mr Power asked the woman - who cannot be identified for legal reasons - why she had never thought of seeing Newland and "Kye" in the same room together as they were both friends.
She replied: "I didn't think anything was unusual, there was always something (a reason) so I didn't think it was odd."
Mr Power then asked when it was the woman's birthday Kye had said he had dropped some stuff off at Gayle's for her and why did she not think that was odd instead of him dropping it off at her own house.
The woman replied: "I had no reason to believe that they were the same person. I was out all day."
The court heard the defence say Kye would visit the alleged victim every Sunday for six or seven hours when they began a physical relationship.
Mr Power questioned the woman how she could be comfortable sitting in a mask and scarf - the items she allegedly forced wear around Kye - for that amount of time.
He said: "Did you never once think that this might not be Kye?"
The woman said: "I had no reason to believe that this wasn't him. It sounds stupid to say but we were in a proper relationship and it was just normal.
"I wish I had just ripped that mask off."
Questioned further about her level of intimacy with Newland the complainant said: "I can't stress enough I felt like I was being made love to by a male.
Mr Power refuted this claim and said: "You knew you were with a woman and you knew it Gayle.
"Are you trying to disguise your sexuality?"
Once again the woman denied Mr Power's questioning and said: "I'm comfortable with who I am, I've never needed to disguise anything."
Questioning further Mr Power said: "You suggested penetrative sex, and she (Gayle) said 'how would we do that?' and you told her to go online."
Again responding to this, the woman in tears said: "No I didn't."
In her victim impact statement shown to the court yesterday on video the woman claimed she had become a shell of her former self since finding out who Kye really was.
She also said she now spends a lot of her time being fearful of making eye contact with people.
The trial continues.