The idea of collecting a list of popes who were sexually active at some point speaks for itself - it's a uniquely Wikipedian way of categorising history in the age of search engines.
But I'm really into the entry's talk page. Since its creation more than a decade ago, this particular list has been argued over, corrected, and expanded with vigour. One user went after some pretty egregious errors when it comes to Catholic terminology. There are also substantial arguments over the neutrality of the entire concept of collecting sexually active popes - whether historically confirmed or not. One lengthy talk thread is titled "Encyclopedia or tabloid?" and several Wikipedians drop in to accuse the entire article of being anti-Catholic, while others defend it.
It might not surprise you to find out that it's been nominated for deletion, twice, and somehow survived. Despite its critics, the page itself has been immortalised (kind of) in an XKCD comic, viewable in the Alt text that pops up when you mouse over one of its images.
- Abby Ohleiser,The Washington Post
Common misconceptions, unusual deaths and uprisings led by women
When the Wikimedia Foundation recently polled its staffers about their favourite pages, these lists of urban legends, weird deaths and under-touted revolutions were among the winners. No explanation necessary, to be honest: They're all self-evidently fascinating.
- The staff of the Wikimedia Foundation
Helicopter prison escapes
Because it makes life seem like a little more like a 1970s New Hollywood action thriller, one that's partly set in France, with exciting scenes involving helicopters and prison escapes.
- William Beutler,Wikipedia commentator
Demon cat
A ghost cat, 10ft (3m) high, which haunts the Washington DC Capitol Buildings. Its home is supposedly the basement crypt of the Capitol that was originally intended as a burial chamber for President George Washington. It explodes when startled.
"The society's version of the story states that a security guard was once licked by a cat when he was lying down. Being drunk, the man thought he was still standing at the time and was frightened by the apparently giant cat."
- Richard Symonds,Wikipedia volunteer
Lists of lists of lists
Look no further than this page's description: "This article is a list of articles that are themselves lists of articles that are also lists on Wikipedia." It takes a few reads to comprehend what you're actually looking at, but this is the epitome of Wikipedia. This web page, I believe, is where the internet starts to devour itself. Also, I like lists.
- Ric Sanchez,The Washington Post
Jesus
The prospect of writing an encyclopedia entry on someone who is indisputably one of the most important figures in history is daunting to say the least. This article is one of the most-linked and most-edited in Wikipedia and is a magnet for virtually every agenda that you can imagine. In spite of this, the article was promoted to Featured status - indicating that it is the highest quality in Wikipedia. Getting to that point required a wealth of the two most fundamental principles of Wikipedia: collaboration with others and good scholarship.
- Justin Anthony Knapp,Wikipedian
Political catchphrases
For the political junkie, this page is like a flash card version of some of the most memorable political catchphrases, gaffes and misspoken statements in world history. You have several well-worn sayings, like the imperial "Veni, vidi, vici" from Julius Caesar to Obama's "Yes we can". But you also find how volatile foreign politics can be. Ireland has four famous phrases with f-bombs in them. During Ontario's 2003 general election, then-Premier Ernie Eves called his opponent an "evil reptilian kitten-eater from another planet". And nothing beats what former New Zealand Prime Minister David Lange said when asked by a journalist for "a brief word" about Australia: "Wombat".
- Gene Park,The Washington Post
What Wikipedia is not
People go to Wikipedia to find out what things are, and I love that an encyclopedia is self-reflective enough to decide what copulae it contains but does not embody.
- Hunter Pauli,Wikipedia enthusiast
Rex Stout bibliography
It may not be "best" in terms of the quality of the prose, but one of my favourite pages is the Rex Stout bibliography, which was split off a few months ago from the main Rex Stout article.
A few years ago, User:WFinch expanded Rex Stout bibliography by adding about a dozen of Stout's earliest stories, which had not been reprinted since their original magazine publications between 1912 and 1918. These stories were unknown even to Stout's academic biographer and bibliographers, but they turned up in the indexing. Members of "the Wolfe Pack" (Stout's literary society or "fan club") asked me about the stories, and I undertook to track them all down ... The Last Drive and Other Stories will be coming out next month, making 11 of Stout's early stories readily available to fans, critics, and scholars for the first time.
Do we owe the book to Wikipedia? Well, it might have happened sooner or later anyway, but the information my friends and I found on Wikipedia is what actually made it happen, and I think Wikipedia gets some of the credit for that.
- Ira Matetsky,Wikipedian
Susan La Flesche Picotte
Sometimes it's not just the article that's inspiring, it's the way it was written. Marie Pellissier was taking Professor Marilynn Johnson's class at Boston College and assigned to write a Wikipedia article about the Wild West. She was surprised to find that so many of the people she could write about were men. So she dug a little deeper into her research, and now there's a Wikipedia article about the first Native American woman doctor, Susan La Flesche Picotte, who helped her tribe stave off tuberculosis and fought for its land use rights.
- Eryk Salvaggio,Wiki Education Foundation
Inventors killed by their own inventions
This list is so ironic. The point of invention is to improve the human experience. For the inventor to be killed is the last thing one would expect or want to do. This says something about the relationship between humans and technology. While lots of good is created, there are downsides we don't always foresee.
- Matt McFarland,The Washington Post
Thomas Jefferson Jackson
For the lede alone: Thomas Jefferson Jackson (T. J. J.) See, (February 19, 1866 - July 4, 1962) was an American astronomer of high potential who ended a colourful life with no real accomplishment in astronomy or physics. He is known for a career dogged by plagiarism, being fired from two observatory staffs, grand egotistical claims, being "exiled" to an isolated outpost, and his vitriolic attacks on relativity.
- Katherine Maher,Wikimedia Foundation
Ebola
Earlier this year when the Ebola epidemic was on the rise, a group of volunteers, a few of them medical professionals, came together with the goal of making Wikipedia a trustworthy resource about Ebola. The article got 17 million views in that month and was translated into many languages. The New York Times covered. This quote talking about James Heilman, a doctor working on the Ebola article, is my favourite: "He is unabashed about his goals: to emphasise that Ebola does not get transmitted through the air; to call out unproven treatments; and to make sure the language is as simple as possible, in part so it can be more easily translated into other languages. 'We don't need to write for experts, experts have lots of excellent sources', he said."
- Moiz Syed,Wikimedia Foundation
Crayola crayon colours
Children of the 80s and 90s, rejoice: There are colour swatches on this page that you didn't even know you wanted to see again. I'm talking the Silver Swirls palette, circa 1992. Glitter crayons. Changeables The Gem Stones set. Colours like maize and blue-green and burnt umber, which - in Crayola form, at least! - no longer exist. It's a weirdly evocative nostalgia-trip, and I highly endorse it. The fact that Wikipedians managed to locate a hex code for each of these colours is also really impressive.
- Caitlin Dewey,The Washington Post
Extreme ironing
This is a thing! End of story.
