Scammed by a guide in Kolkata

He said his name was Stephen and my father and I were too weary to disbelieve him. It was only mid-morning near Kolkata's Dalhousie Square and already we were worn down by the press of hands-out humanity, hucksters and humidity.

So when Stephen walked up and introduced himself we kept moving. He asked the usual persistent questions: "Can I help you in any way, gentlemen? Would you like to visit my shop?"

We ignored all these - we had heard them a dozen times in the previous half hour - but then he asked where we were from and my spirit must have broken. I told him.

"But this is extraordinary," he said bouncing with delight. "I have a brother in Pukekohe near Auckland. Where are you from? What a marvellous coincidence."

Stephen was small but solidly built, crisply dressed in well-pressed slacks and white, short-sleeved shirt, and had impenetrably dark eyes which darted with excitement beneath enormously thick eyebrows.

He would consider it an honour, a privilege even, to show us around his wonderful city - and because we came from New Zealand he would take us places no other tourist would see.

And he would do all this for a nominal fee, cheaper than an official guide. He quoted a price and insisted we could go back to our hotel to compare.

The humanity, hucksters and humidity had got the better of us and we agreed to go with him. By the slightest hand gesture he conjured up an Ambassador taxi which had been quietly cruising behind us, driven by an enormous Sikh.

Stephen extolled the virtues of New Zealand - a very beautiful country, his brother had told him - and said he was saving to go for a visit.

But, of course, he would have to get back home quickly because he was an accountant, and this was his day off. Or something like that.

But he did take us to some memorable places, notably a temple some kilometres away through endless dusty streets. There, we waited in the taxi while he negotiated with the local priest for us to look around. There was much waving of hands and, eventually, he gestured us forward.

We walked up the long path, shaking hands with the priest, all the while watched warily by many and various old men and women. Stephen had negotiated a price of 20 rupees for us to take as many photographs as we wanted.

Around the back, women were gathered around the burning body of someone's husband down by the river. I asked what the round stones were piled up in the muddy water where people bathed and washed.

"Nevilles," said Stephen.

Nevilles?

"Yes, Nevilles."

We moved on, me frowning and him leading us around to where the Tiger Man lived. On the riverbank was a three-sided concrete box the size of a telephone booth. In the centre was a hole in the earth and around it were framed photographs of an enormous man swathed in a tiger skin, his thick hair pulled back and so long it curled around his ankles.

His beard reached his knees. He was a fierce sight and Stephen said he was a wise man who lived down the hole and came out only at night to take the food left by local woman.

Encouraged by the local priest, we banged off some more photos and headed back to the temple.

I looked at the smooth stones in the river and asked again.

"Nevilles, yes. After someone dies they cut out the nevilles and put them in hollowed stones then put them in the river. It is the sacred Hooghly River and the nevilles are being returned to the Mother."

I looked at the dirty river full of navels, the women washing their clothes on the bank opposite, the women nearby crying by the pyre.

It was time to leave. The local holy man came up with his hand out, 20 rupees. My dad paid him. A howl of anguish and shouting. A crowd suddenly gathers. Stephen backs off.

Now the deal has changed, 20 rupees for each photograph. We dispute this, Stephen is pulled into the fray and doesn't know which side to take. We give him maybe 100 rupees and make for the taxi waiting at the end of the driveway. We are followed by howls of injustice, and Stephen.

He jumps back in the cab, the mob are banging on the taxi roof, Stephen tells our driver to go. It has turned into a nightmare.

Our Sikh slowly negotiates his way through the gathering crowd and we speed off.

Near our hotel an unusual thing happens. Stephen spots a long-lost friend in the crowd and asks the driver to pull over. If we could just pay him now he could catch his friend. So we do and he peels off some rupees for the driver who will take us back to our hotel.

Stephen pumps our hands furiously and says he hopes to see us in New Zealand next year, then disappears into the melee.

A little distance from our hotel, the driver stops the car, turns in his seat and asks for payment. We say he has been paid by Stephen.

"No. That was for one person. Now you pay for the other." So who was scamming who here? Had Stephen scammed the driver, or was the driver now scamming us?

We didn't care either way. For the second time that day we do a runner.

The driver stayed outside out hotel for an hour shouting insults with the assistance of a gathered crowd until they were hurried off or got sick of the stand-off.

It was a nightmare of a day, only hilarious in retrospect.

That night I checked how much an official guide would have been. Stephen had stiffed us for half as much again. Of course.

You know, I don't think his name was Stephen. And he probably didn't have a brother in Pukekohe either.