In the last few months, the holiday hotspot has proposed a ban on tourists using motorbikes, called for a campaign to educate foreign guests amid unruly behaviour, talked about a tax on tourists – and now it’s targeting tourists working illegally.
A special task force has been set up, made up of local officials and the immigration office, to monitor foreigners’ activities.
Bali Chamber of Commerce and Industry chair Made Ariandi said non-citizens were not allowed to work, and that starting businesses or taking jobs illegally negatively impacted local entrepreneurs.
“It is never too late. We have confidence, sincerity, togetherness and collaboration with all stakeholders,” he said.
It’s reported that while many visit Bali for tourism purposes at first, some end up opening businesses illegally.
Ariandi said this has been especially seen after the pandemic and can be attributed to the visa on arrival (VoA) and the second home visa policies.
“[Foreigners] live very cheaply in Indonesia. The fear is that the world community who travel here ‘feels like’ living here. If they stay, they will open businesses or work,” he said.
Indonesia’s VoA programme allows foreigners to visit Indonesia for 30 days for tourism and is open to more than 80 countries. It costs about $50.
Bali has become a popular place to live and work for cheap. Picture / Supplied.
Overstaying the visa can lead to fines of $110 per day, or being detained, deported or banned from Indonesia for a specific period.
A second home visa is a non-work visa that came into effect in Bali in December 2022.
It is granted to foreigners and their families who want to live permanently in Indonesia for five or 10 years.
The visa programme aims to attract wealthy foreigners, where applicants must show proof of funds to live on and a further 2 billion rupiah, or $220,000, to be placed in an Indonesian government-owned bank.
Another option of eligibility is owning property of a similar value and while foreigners cannot own land in Indonesia, they can lease land and own a property on it.
It’s also not legal to make an income from any home while living in Indonesia on the second home visa.
“The 2 billion rupiah is not for investment but to ensure visitors can stay two to three years without starving,” Ariandi said.
“If they have money, they won’t starve and won’t take up someone else’s or [a] local’s job.”
The second home visas are about attracting wealthy tourists who can afford to live in Indonesia and contribute to the economy by spending, not working.
Bali Kadin of the Chamber of Commerce and Industry said: “The tourists need to be aware. [The second home visa] does not mean they can spend millions of rupiah then run out of money and become motorcycle taxi [ojek] drivers, gymnastics, and yoga teachers, diving coaches, and anything else.”
Many remote workers are able to work and play in Bali. Photo / Olivier Desire
Bali Tourism Office head Tjok Bagus Pemayun recently said Indonesia has a strict working visa policy that must be followed by foreign nationals, as any violations of the working regulation will harm locals in Bali.
“I cannot determine [the sanction], but we will follow all regulations. Any deportations will be done if necessary. We have no target, as our focus is to follow all regulations,” he said.
The Manpower and Energy and Mineral Resources Office head IB Setiawan also said the task force would screen the foreign nationals’ data, as one challenge in the monitoring works is to assess the incoming and outgoing data.
Meanwhile, according to The Strait Times 47 people, including 13 Russians, have since been deported for violating their stay conditions and misusing the residence permit.
One Ukrainian citizen is also being processed through the courts after allegedly being found holding a fake Indonesian national ID, the publication reported.
Bali Governor Wayan Koster revealed this month he was asking the Indonesian government to stop Russian and Ukrainian tourists from being allowed to get a visa on arrival in the country.
At a news conference in Denpasar, Koster said Russians and Ukrainians were coming to Bali to escape the war, and were not just there for leisure but to find work.
He claimed the two nationalities made up the highest number of violations among foreigners, according to local media.
The founder of a luxury shoe brand in Bali, Niluh Djelantik, said: “We opened our doors, we opened our arms, and we welcomed them with a big smile. But our kindness has been taken for granted.”
“There are many visa violations, like tourists who take jobs, economic crimes, overstays,” Koster told the Wall Street Journal, speaking of Ukrainian and Russian visitors.
