A High Court judge appears to have kept all sides of the Himalayan tahr argument happy.
The Tahr Foundation, representing hunters, claimed a victory when Justice Robert Dobson ruled last night the Department of Conservation must consult it over its plan to eradicate tahr from the Aoraki/Mount Cook and Westland Tai Poutini National Parks.
Forest and Bird expressed its satisfaction Justice Dobson ruled there was "no constraint on the types of tahr that may be controlled", meaning DoC could include in its cull bull tahr, prized by trophy hunters.
And Doc has been allowed to undertake half of its planned 250 hours of helicopter hunting while the consultation is going on.
Justice Dobson ruled DoC must "reconsider its decision" to proceed with its eradication plan, and either amend the plan or provide reasons for not doing so.