The council's policy and bylaw committee heard submissions on Thursday and voted for 50km/h speed limits on all four roads.
Bill Simmons presented a submission on behalf of 38 residents recommending a 60km/h speed limit for the four roads, saying the council's preferred options were "arbitrary and unfounded".
Simmons argued that a 50km/h speed limit would "urbanise" the rural area.
"Rural roads are not a pedestrian precinct," he said.
"A 50km speed limit is an indelible icon of urbanisation."
Simmons said the council's preferred limit would conflict with the District Plan objectives for the zone and would compromise its rural "character and amenity".
Councillors commended Simmons on the amount of work that had gone into the submission which included photos, diagrams and empirical data but questioned whether the signatories had been given accurate information.
Submitter Murray Hughes said he would prefer a 40km/h option for the area but was happy to support the proposed 50km/h limit.
Hughes' submission stated that some signatories of the 60km/h petition had been led to believe that a 50km/h limit would require the council to install footpaths and lighting.
"Fox Rd and Portal St have 50km/h speed limits and don't have footpaths or lighting," Hughes said.
Councillor Kate Joblin said she understood the council budget had no money for new footpaths and questioned council senior policy analyst Justin Walters who said decisions around the installation of infrastructure were not related to speed limits.