The pace in the five-man final of 20 sheep was led by far-travelled Northland gun Toa Henderson of Kaiwaka, who finished in 16min 38sec - almost half a minute before next-man-off Fagan.
However, in the final count, Fagan beat Masterton shearer Paerata Abraham by 0.7 points.
Third place went to Eketahuna shearer Hemi Braddick, who was trying to repeat a Gisborne win from 12 months earlier, the first open win of his career.
In the end, Henderson had to settle for fourth place.
Multiple champion woolhandler Joel Henare returned to his hometown to win a ninth Gisborne open woolhandling title and the 134th open win of his career.
Henare’s success spearheaded several hometown successes on the day.
Read more Shearing and Woolhandling stories on The Country here.
Brittany Tibble, of Gisborne, was second, the senior and intermediate shearing titles went to Gisborne competitors Te Ua Wilcox and Dylan Young respectively, and the senior and junior woolhandling titles also went to Gisborne competitors, Traemon Campbell and Renee Apanui respectively.
The next competition in the North Island is the Great Raihania Shears Shearing and Woolhandling Championships on Friday at the Hawke’s Bay A and P Show in Hastings.
Results from the Gisborne Shearing and Woolhandling Championships
Shearing:
Open final (20 sheep): Jack Fagan (Te Kuiti) 17min 7sec, 61.5pts, 1; Paerata Abraham (Masterton) 17min 10sec, 62.2pts, 2; Hemi Braddick (Eketahuna) 17min 41sec, 62.5pts, 3; Toa Henderson (Kaiwaka) 16min 38sec, 63.6pts, 4; Tama Nia Nia (Gisborne) 18min 50sec, 64.95pts, 5.
Senior final (10 sheep): Te Ua Wilcox (Gisborne) 11min 25sec, 41.75pts, 1; Bruce Grace (Wairoa) 12min 34sec, 46.9pts, 2; David Hodge (Te Puke) 13min 33sec, 52.15pts, 3; Jack Hutchison (-) 13min 6sec, 56.1pts, 4; Jake Williams (-) 11min 12sec, 58.1pts, 5.
Intermediate final (5 sheep): Dylan Young (Gisborne) 7min 28sec, 35.6pts, 1; Ryka Swann (Wairoa) 8min 25sec, 42.65pts, 2; Cheyden Winiata (Nuhaka) 8min 27sec, 45.75pts, 3; Sam Parker (Raglan) 8min 25sec, 49.25pts, 4; Matekino Puhia (Raupunga) 7min 16sec, 61.8pts, 5.
Junior final (4 sheep): Kaivah Cooper (Napier) 8min, 37.75pts, 1; Tom Kerley (Wairoa) 23min 3sec, 46.4pts, 2; Raupunga Puhia (Raupunga) 6min 18sec, 53.65pts, 3; Jodiesha Kirkpatrick (Gisborne) 11min 5sec, 54pts, 4; Roy Pomare (Gisborne) 7min 17sec, 60.1pts, 5.
Woolhandling:
Open final: Joel Henare (Gisborne) 126.8pts, 1; Brittany Tibble (Gisborne) 225pts, 2; Keryn Herbert (Te Kuiti) 229pts, 3; Samantha Gordon (Masterton) 266.6pts, 4.
Senior final: Tramon Campbell (Gisborne) 135pts, 1; Anne Connell (Gisborne) 164pts, 2; Rahera Kerr (Hauturu) 186pts, 3; Te Whetu Brown (Wairoa/Napier) 187.6pts, 4.
Junior final: Renee Apanui (-) 122.8pts, 1; Jodiesha Kirkpatrick (Gisborne) 125.6pts, 2; Kelly Barrett (-) 127.4pts, 3; Waiari Puna (Napier) 128.4pts, 4.Novice: Shaquille Hauiti (-) 48.6pts, 1; Kalyah Ferguson (Waipawa) 57pts, 2; Layiss Atkins (-) 72pts, 3; Peti Biddle (-) 75.8pts, 4; Aqua Lee Ruru (-) 80.2pts, 5.