It's every hitch-hiker's nightmare, jumping into a car with a serial killer or dangerous criminal.
So when Newstalk ZB talkback radio host James Daniels and his wife accepted a ride while on holiday in the Cook Islands, they were stunned when their driver introduced himself as one of Rarotonga's most notorious criminals.
They were even more shocked when the affable man in his 60s disclosed what his current job happened to be, handing over his Ministry of Corrective Services business card with a smile.
After spending an idyllic holiday on the island of Aitutaki recently, for their last morning in Rarotonga, Daniels said he and wife Dianne decided to spend it at Avarua's bustling Punanga Nui Saturday Market.
But what happened next left Barnett aghast - and in hysterics.
The story began with Daniels, 67, saying that after they missed the bus from Rarotonga International Airport, the couple decided to try their hand at hitching a ride to the popular market.
Daniels said the man shared his criminal past, saying he had "done a few things" - from starting a gang in the 70s to stealing and attempting to burn down the government house*.
"I'm already freaking," Daniels explained.
"And I was sitting in this car, he's driving along, and I was thinking: 'Was there any kidnapping on that list!'?"
Barnett was in hysterics at the tale, laughing at Daniels' retelling of their odd-ball hitch-hiking experience.
The radio co-host then asked the man: "What are you doing now?"
To which he astoundingly replied that he was now the Minister of Corrective Services in the Cook Islands.
"Everyone knows him. They're all waving and saying: 'Hey George'. He winds down his window and points to us."
Barnett said to Daniels: "What an amazing and extraordinary story."
Subsequent text messages into the station revealed how much listeners loved the story.
As memorable as their first hitchhiking experience was, they have decided to never attempt to thumb a ride again, Daniels said.
But now they have a great dinner travel story to share for years to come.
*On the radio recording, Daniels misheard Angene say he came out of prison in 2017 and that he had attempted to burn down government house. However, the now veteran MP was in fact paroled and released from prison more than 22 years ago for arson to the ministry of justice, post office and telecom building centre.