NZ Herald
  • Home
  • Latest news
  • Herald NOW
  • Video
  • New Zealand
  • Sport
  • World
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Podcasts
  • Quizzes
  • Opinion
  • Lifestyle
  • Travel
  • Viva
  • Weather

Subscriptions

  • Herald Premium
  • Viva Premium
  • The Listener
  • BusinessDesk

Sections

  • Latest news
  • New Zealand
    • All New Zealand
    • Crime
    • Politics
    • Education
    • Open Justice
    • Scam Update
  • Herald NOW
  • On The Up
  • World
    • All World
    • Australia
    • Asia
    • UK
    • United States
    • Middle East
    • Europe
    • Pacific
  • Business
    • All Business
    • MarketsSharesCurrencyCommoditiesStock TakesCrypto
    • Markets with Madison
    • Media Insider
    • Business analysis
    • Personal financeKiwiSaverInterest ratesTaxInvestment
    • EconomyInflationGDPOfficial cash rateEmployment
    • Small business
    • Business reportsMood of the BoardroomProject AucklandSustainable business and financeCapital markets reportAgribusiness reportInfrastructure reportDynamic business
    • Deloitte Top 200 Awards
    • CompaniesAged CareAgribusinessAirlinesBanking and financeConstructionEnergyFreight and logisticsHealthcareManufacturingMedia and MarketingRetailTelecommunicationsTourism
  • Opinion
    • All Opinion
    • Analysis
    • Editorials
    • Business analysis
    • Premium opinion
    • Letters to the editor
  • Politics
  • Sport
    • All Sport
    • OlympicsParalympics
    • RugbySuper RugbyNPCAll BlacksBlack FernsRugby sevensSchool rugby
    • CricketBlack CapsWhite Ferns
    • Racing
    • NetballSilver Ferns
    • LeagueWarriorsNRL
    • FootballWellington PhoenixAuckland FCAll WhitesFootball FernsEnglish Premier League
    • GolfNZ Open
    • MotorsportFormula 1
    • Boxing
    • UFC
    • BasketballNBABreakersTall BlacksTall Ferns
    • Tennis
    • Cycling
    • Athletics
    • SailingAmerica's CupSailGP
    • Rowing
  • Lifestyle
    • All Lifestyle
    • Viva - Food, fashion & beauty
    • Society Insider
    • Royals
    • Sex & relationships
    • Food & drinkRecipesRecipe collectionsRestaurant reviewsRestaurant bookings
    • Health & wellbeing
    • Fashion & beauty
    • Pets & animals
    • The Selection - Shop the trendsShop fashionShop beautyShop entertainmentShop giftsShop home & living
    • Milford's Investing Place
  • Entertainment
    • All Entertainment
    • TV
    • MoviesMovie reviews
    • MusicMusic reviews
    • BooksBook reviews
    • Culture
    • ReviewsBook reviewsMovie reviewsMusic reviewsRestaurant reviews
  • Travel
    • All Travel
    • News
    • New ZealandNorthlandAucklandWellingtonCanterburyOtago / QueenstownNelson-TasmanBest NZ beaches
    • International travelAustraliaPacific IslandsEuropeUKUSAAfricaAsia
    • Rail holidays
    • Cruise holidays
    • Ski holidays
    • Luxury travel
    • Adventure travel
  • Kāhu Māori news
  • Environment
    • All Environment
    • Our Green Future
  • Talanoa Pacific news
  • Property
    • All Property
    • Property Insider
    • Interest rates tracker
    • Residential property listings
    • Commercial property listings
  • Health
  • Technology
    • All Technology
    • AI
    • Social media
  • Rural
    • All Rural
    • Dairy farming
    • Sheep & beef farming
    • Horticulture
    • Animal health
    • Rural business
    • Rural life
    • Rural technology
    • Opinion
    • Audio & podcasts
  • Weather forecasts
    • All Weather forecasts
    • Kaitaia
    • Whangārei
    • Dargaville
    • Auckland
    • Thames
    • Tauranga
    • Hamilton
    • Whakatāne
    • Rotorua
    • Tokoroa
    • Te Kuiti
    • Taumaranui
    • Taupō
    • Gisborne
    • New Plymouth
    • Napier
    • Hastings
    • Dannevirke
    • Whanganui
    • Palmerston North
    • Levin
    • Paraparaumu
    • Masterton
    • Wellington
    • Motueka
    • Nelson
    • Blenheim
    • Westport
    • Reefton
    • Kaikōura
    • Greymouth
    • Hokitika
    • Christchurch
    • Ashburton
    • Timaru
    • Wānaka
    • Oamaru
    • Queenstown
    • Dunedin
    • Gore
    • Invercargill
  • Meet the journalists
  • Promotions & competitions
  • OneRoof property listings
  • Driven car news

Puzzles & Quizzes

  • Puzzles
    • All Puzzles
    • Sudoku
    • Code Cracker
    • Crosswords
    • Cryptic crossword
    • Wordsearch
  • Quizzes
    • All Quizzes
    • Morning quiz
    • Afternoon quiz
    • Sports quiz

Regions

  • Northland
    • All Northland
    • Far North
    • Kaitaia
    • Kerikeri
    • Kaikohe
    • Bay of Islands
    • Whangarei
    • Dargaville
    • Kaipara
    • Mangawhai
  • Auckland
  • Waikato
    • All Waikato
    • Hamilton
    • Coromandel & Hauraki
    • Matamata & Piako
    • Cambridge
    • Te Awamutu
    • Tokoroa & South Waikato
    • Taupō & Tūrangi
  • Bay of Plenty
    • All Bay of Plenty
    • Katikati
    • Tauranga
    • Mount Maunganui
    • Pāpāmoa
    • Te Puke
    • Whakatāne
  • Rotorua
  • Hawke's Bay
    • All Hawke's Bay
    • Napier
    • Hastings
    • Havelock North
    • Central Hawke's Bay
    • Wairoa
  • Taranaki
    • All Taranaki
    • Stratford
    • New Plymouth
    • Hāwera
  • Manawatū - Whanganui
    • All Manawatū - Whanganui
    • Whanganui
    • Palmerston North
    • Manawatū
    • Tararua
    • Horowhenua
  • Wellington
    • All Wellington
    • Kapiti
    • Wairarapa
    • Upper Hutt
    • Lower Hutt
  • Nelson & Tasman
    • All Nelson & Tasman
    • Motueka
    • Nelson
    • Tasman
  • Marlborough
  • West Coast
  • Canterbury
    • All Canterbury
    • Kaikōura
    • Christchurch
    • Ashburton
    • Timaru
  • Otago
    • All Otago
    • Oamaru
    • Dunedin
    • Balclutha
    • Alexandra
    • Queenstown
    • Wanaka
  • Southland
    • All Southland
    • Invercargill
    • Gore
    • Stewart Island
  • Gisborne

Media

  • Video
    • All Video
    • NZ news video
    • Herald NOW
    • Business news video
    • Politics news video
    • Sport video
    • World news video
    • Lifestyle video
    • Entertainment video
    • Travel video
    • Markets with Madison
    • Kea Kids news
  • Podcasts
    • All Podcasts
    • The Front Page
    • On the Tiles
    • Ask me Anything
    • The Little Things
  • Cartoons
  • Photo galleries
  • Today's Paper - E-editions
  • Photo sales
  • Classifieds

NZME Network

  • Advertise with NZME
  • OneRoof
  • Driven Car Guide
  • BusinessDesk
  • Newstalk ZB
  • Sunlive
  • ZM
  • The Hits
  • Coast
  • Radio Hauraki
  • The Alternative Commentary Collective
  • Gold
  • Flava
  • iHeart Radio
  • Hokonui
  • Radio Wanaka
  • iHeartCountry New Zealand
  • Restaurant Hub
  • NZME Events

SubscribeSign In
Advertisement
Advertise with NZME.
Home / Sport

'Trans women are not taking over': Sport is again divided over inclusiveness and a level playing field

By Jeré Longman
New York Times·
22 Jun, 2022 10:44 PM5 mins to read

Subscribe to listen

Access to Herald Premium articles require a Premium subscription. Subscribe now to listen.
Already a subscriber?  Sign in here

Listening to articles is free for open-access content—explore other articles or learn more about text-to-speech.
‌
Save

    Share this article

    Reminder, this is a Premium article and requires a subscription to read.

US swimmer Lia Thomas. Photo / AP

US swimmer Lia Thomas. Photo / AP

Advertisement
Advertise with NZME.

Should the primary aim of elite sports be competitive fairness? Or does maintaining integrity mean that inclusiveness is just as important as a level playing field?

The issue, which has roiled the water of pools everywhere with the success of Lia Thomas, the transgender University of Pennsylvania swimmer, burst to the surface again on Sunday. FINA, swimming's world governing body, essentially prohibited transgender women from the highest levels of women's international competition.

FINA's proposal is to create a so-called open category of competition to "protect competitive fairness". But a separate category is "isolating, demeaning and has the potential to make transgender and nonbinary competitors into a spectacle on an international stage", Anne Lieberman, the director of policy and programmes at Athlete Ally, which seeks to end transphobia and homophobia in sports, said on Wednesday.

The attempt to balance inclusiveness and fairness, especially regarding the eligibility of transgender and intersex athletes (competitors with the typical male pattern of X and Y chromosomes) is among the most complicated and divisive issues in sports.

Reasoned arguments are made on both sides. Going through puberty as a male provides physical advantages that persist even after testosterone levels are suppressed, such as broader shoulders, bigger hands, longer torsos, denser muscles and greater heart and lung capacity.

Advertisement
Advertise with NZME.
South African long distance athlete Caster Semenya. Photo / AP
South African long distance athlete Caster Semenya. Photo / AP

In January, the international and European federations of sports medicine issued a joint statement that said, in part, high testosterone concentrations "confer a baseline advantage for athletes in certain sports" and that to uphold "the integrity and fairness of sport" these advantages "must be recognised and mitigated".

Yet there has been relatively little scientific research involving elite transgender athletes. And studies have not quantified testosterone's precise impact on performance. The governing body of track and field, which has instituted stringent regulations on permitted levels of testosterone, last year corrected its own research. It acknowledged that it could not confirm a causal relationship between elevated testosterone levels and performance advantages for elite female athletes.

FINA left itself vulnerable to critics who charge that it acted hastily and recklessly, taking retribution against Thomas and trying to create a solution for a problem that doesn't exist. The Human Rights Campaign, an LGBTQ civil rights organisation, blamed the swimming governing body for "caving to the avalanche of ill-informed, prejudiced attacks targeted at one particular transgender swimmer".

Advertisement
Advertise with NZME.

Only one known transgender athlete has won an Olympic medal in a women's competition, Canadian soccer player Quinn, who was assigned female at birth and identifies as nonbinary. And only two openly transgender female athletes appear to have won NCAA titles — Thomas and CeCe Telfer, who won the 400-metre hurdles race for Division II Franklin Pierce University in 2019.

Even in victory, Thomas did not deliver a shattering performance at the NCAA championships in March. Her winning time in the 500-yard freestyle race was nine seconds off the collegiate record set by Katie Ledecky for Stanford University in 2017. Thomas finished fifth in the 200 freestyle and last in the final of the 100 freestyle.

Discover more

Sport

D'Arcy Waldegrave: The far-reaching consequences of sport's transgender row

22 Jun 08:00 PM
Opinion

Shane Te Pou: Tolerance needed in face of people's fear of unknown

22 Jun 05:00 PM
Athletics

Caster Semenya: 'Athletics chiefs thought I had a d*** so I offered to prove I didn't'

23 May 10:30 PM
League

Rugby league bans transgender athletes from international competition

21 Jun 12:25 AM

"It's very unfortunate that FINA has made this ruling," Joanna Harper, a medical physicist who has researched and written extensively about transgender athletes, told The New York Times on Sunday. "Trans women are not taking over women's sports, and they are not going to."

Will others follow swimming?

Will any other international sports federations follow swimming's lead? Some predict track and field could be next, drawn to FINA's solution to the thorny issue of what levels of testosterone should be permissible. Swimming's rule prohibits transgender women from competing unless they began medical treatments to suppress production of testosterone before going through one of the early stages of puberty, or by age 12, whichever occurred later. There is much debate in the medical community about such early intervention.

Would the Court of Arbitration for Sport — a kind of Supreme Court for international sports — overrule FINA's decision, if it is challenged? History suggests otherwise.

South African champion runner Caster Semenya lost her attempt before that court to overturn track and field's testosterone rules, effectively ending her Olympic career. CAS ruled in 2019 that track's policy was "discriminatory" but also "necessary, reasonable and proportionate" to ensure fair play in women's events.

Two senior CAS arbitrators, including the lead arbitrator in Semenya's case, were among FINA's legal and human rights experts and were satisfied that the federation's policy met the "necessary and proportionate" standard, Doriane Lambelet Coleman, a Duke law professor who specialises in sex and gender and who helped draft FINA's policy, said on Wednesday.

In November, the International Olympic Committee cautioned against presuming, without evidence, that athletes have an unfair competitive advantage "due to their sex variations, physical appearance and/or transgender status". But this was only a guiding principle. The IOC has ceded the determination of eligibility rules to international sports federations.

Advertisement
Advertise with NZME.

A complicated situation could get even messier. Say, for instance, USA Swimming ignores FINA's policy as the Paris Olympics arrive in 2024. That could leave Thomas in the awkward position of earning a spot on the US Olympic team but being ineligible to compete in Paris. FINA's policy would prevail over USA Swimming's policy.

Only one thing seems certain, Tommy Lundberg, a Swedish researcher who has studied transgender athletes, told the Times in 2020. "It is going to be impossible," he said, "to make everyone happy."

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.


Written by: Jeré Longman
© 2022 THE NEW YORK TIMES

Save

    Share this article

    Reminder, this is a Premium article and requires a subscription to read.

Latest from Sport

Black Caps

‘World-class performer’: Ajaz Patel thrown Black Caps lifeline by new coach

11 Jul 06:00 PM
Sport|rugby

O’Connor returns as Wallabies prepare for British and Irish Lions

11 Jul 07:56 AM
World

Aussie sporting first in racial abuse arrest

11 Jul 04:15 AM

From early mornings to easy living

sponsored
Advertisement
Advertise with NZME.

Latest from Sport

‘World-class performer’: Ajaz Patel thrown Black Caps lifeline by new coach

‘World-class performer’: Ajaz Patel thrown Black Caps lifeline by new coach

11 Jul 06:00 PM

‘I don’t think he’s ever let the team down’.

O’Connor returns as Wallabies prepare for British and Irish Lions

O’Connor returns as Wallabies prepare for British and Irish Lions

11 Jul 07:56 AM
Aussie sporting first in racial abuse arrest

Aussie sporting first in racial abuse arrest

11 Jul 04:15 AM
The story so far: Tafa set to begin new chapter in UFC career

The story so far: Tafa set to begin new chapter in UFC career

11 Jul 03:35 AM
Solar bat monitors uncover secrets of Auckland’s night sky
sponsored

Solar bat monitors uncover secrets of Auckland’s night sky

NZ Herald
  • About NZ Herald
  • Meet the journalists
  • Newsletters
  • Classifieds
  • Help & support
  • Contact us
  • House rules
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of use
  • Competition terms & conditions
  • Our use of AI
Subscriber Services
  • NZ Herald e-editions
  • Daily puzzles & quizzes
  • Manage your digital subscription
  • Manage your print subscription
  • Subscribe to the NZ Herald newspaper
  • Subscribe to Herald Premium
  • Gift a subscription
  • Subscriber FAQs
  • Subscription terms & conditions
  • Promotions and subscriber benefits
NZME Network
  • The New Zealand Herald
  • The Northland Age
  • The Northern Advocate
  • Waikato Herald
  • Bay of Plenty Times
  • Rotorua Daily Post
  • Hawke's Bay Today
  • Whanganui Chronicle
  • Viva
  • NZ Listener
  • Newstalk ZB
  • BusinessDesk
  • OneRoof
  • Driven Car Guide
  • iHeart Radio
  • Restaurant Hub
NZME
  • About NZME
  • NZME careers
  • Advertise with NZME
  • Digital self-service advertising
  • Book your classified ad
  • Photo sales
  • NZME Events
  • © Copyright 2025 NZME Publishing Limited
TOP