• 'The ASB Classic is on life support now' - tennis fans fuming after shock exit of Venus Williams and Ana Ivanovic
• Tennis: Queen of Auckland dumped in first-round upset
The 35-year-old Williams plays a high risk game, relying on overwhelming her opponents with a deluge of winners. When her radar is off, as it was on Tuesday, and she faces someone who returns everything, she is vulnerable.
Ivanovic is always a nervy starter at tournaments, and faced a qualifier who had been tuned up by three tough games. Naomi Broady played the game of her life - Ivanovic compared her serving performance to Serena Williams - and the second seed was gone.
But there is no suggestion that either player "tanked", or gave up. They are both too competitive for that, and desperately needed the match fitness at this time of year.
The pair have been loyal to Auckland, as both players could receive greater financial incentives to play elsewhere. They are also two of the more obliging stars on the tour in terms of fulfilling media and sponsor commitments.
It was a disaster for the profile of the tournament, but won't affect the bottom line, as most of the tickets have already been sold. And it could have actually been worse; the WTA tournament in Brisbane this week lost drawcards Maria Sharapova and Simona Halep before it had started, with the European duo pulling out with injuries, as did Serena Williams at the Hopman Cup.
The tournament - and Auckland fans - have been fortunate over the past three years, as the marquee names have reached the final on each occasion. But look at the champions before that; Zheng Jie, Greta Arn, Yanina Wickmayer.
Tennis is an unpredictable contest and that is what makes it so appealing.
If there was one question mark, one might ask why Venus Williams was gallivanting around with some All Blacks on Monday for a sponsor's commercial, less than 48 hours after she arrived in the country?
Ideally, she would have been resting but without sponsorship appearances it wouldn't be possible to bring these tennis stars to the country.