Australia's Mick Fanning missed a chance to claim his third world surfing championship when he was beaten in the quarter-finals at the Portugal Pro.
NSW surfer Kai Otton won their heat with 10 points to Fanning's 9.43 in inconsistent 1m waves at Peniche.
Otton then accounted for world champion Joel Parkinson in the semis and won his maiden world tour event by beating rookie of the year Nat Young in the final.
The 33-year-old Otton compiled 12.23 points to the American's 11.03.
It was the first ever final for Otton in his seven years on the elite tour.