Referee Wayne Barnes shows the way on TMOs

Name: All Blacks: TMO's and slowing the game
Uploaded: 2015-09-29T21:59:49+13:00
Duration: 293 s
Description: The All Blacks can only control their side of the match and what they do, but the slowing down of matches via injuries, TMO decisions and slow play can only disadvantage a team that relies on fitness to finish strongly and win. They speak post the Namibia match about the speed of play as it could become more of an issuse as Rugby World Cup continues.

By Wynne Gray

NZ Herald·

29 Sep, 2015 08:30 PM3 mins to read

The All Blacks can only control their side of the match and what they do, but the slowing down of matches via injuries, TMO decisions and slow play can only disadvantage a team that relies on fitness to finish strongly and win. They speak post the Namibia match about the speed of play as it could become more of an issuse as Rugby World Cup continues.

Wayne Barnes has been in charge for two World Cup games. So far so good.

He's not my favourite referee, and not because of any residual resentment about 2007. At times he seems to be in the wrong place to make judgments but his work in the Springboks-Samoa clash was spot on.

There's been way too much interference from the TMOs and even greater reliance on the video replay screen at this World Cup but Barnes bossed the business at Villa Park.

At one stage, touch judge Angus Gardner, who was assertive during the Super Rugby series, waltzed on calling for Springboks wing JP Pietersen to be sent to the sinbin for a high shot on Alesanna Tuilagi.

Barnes called up the replay and, it seemed, without any further chat with his TMO or Gardner, ignored that recommendation and warned Tuilagi about exploiting the challenge.

Early in the second half there was another incident and the players started pestering Barnes to go to the TMO for further judgment.

Barnes asked whether they were questioning his ability. In that instant, there was further confirmation about the danger for rugby if they widen the use of replays. The more it is used, the more players will use it for their perceived advantage.

It's easy to imagine those ugly pileups which blight football matches when players harangue match officials, often jostling them or their opponents.

There was a rugby convention the referee would converse only with the captains of both teams during a match. Some of that strictness has eased but, in this World Cup, it seems to be taking on another life.

The cause of that can only be the excessive referrals to the TMO, which started in the opening game at Twickenham when Jaco Peyper and his deputies blinked at every roar from the crowd.

Rugby is an imperfect sport with a bloated book of rules. Widening the scope of the TMO for decisions other than foul play outside a scoring movement will open up the system to extended abuse. It's also a handy vehicle for sides feeling the fitness pinch to implore the referee to check the big screen for some make-believe indiscretion.

World Rugby officials have been trawling through all the footage and citing players for actions they felt were unlawful. Some have been upheld, like the eye-gouging from Pumas lock Mariano Galarza, although it was odd they did not cite England flanker Tom Wood for his kick which connected with the Welsh fullback's head.

Picking through those details afterwards is an appropriate way to judge any foul play which has not been clear to the match officials.

Those individuals should take note of Barnes' work - as long as he continues to take charge as he did at Villa Park.

Want to banter with the best in the business? Join the conversation on the Veitchy on Sport Facebook page