Whatever the validity of the criticism - there is no doubt New Zealand was getting a little overwrought by the possibility that they might, as the world's leading rugby nation, again fail to reproduce their one and only world title performance in the inaugural tournament in 1987 - Sir Fred and Old Buck, who is a mere 53 and the winner of a battle with cancer, could hardly be accused of going over the top.
Had they done so, it would have been a somewhat bizarre betrayal of the meaning of their lives.
Sir Fred, a bold, side-stepping five-eighths, suffered some early career disruption with the need to serve in the 27th and 30th Battalions of the New Zealand Expeditionary Force in World War II, from which he emerged as one of the jewels in a New Zealand service team which toured Britain in 1946.
He played 21 matches for the All Blacks, all of them as captain, and in a two-year stint as coach he won all his 14 games, partly through the brilliant contribution of his massive player Brian Lochore, the inspiration of a team rated by many the finest to visit Britain and France, and also because his ability to analyse performance was so acute - which was one reason, along with the fact that he earned his living by manufacturing women's dresses, he was known as "The Needle".
Shelford is ranked as one of the greatest No 8s who, between 1987 and 1990, led an unbeaten All Black team with blood-curdling intensity.
In one of his early test matches, the Battle of Nantes against France, he insisted a physiotherapist sew up his torn scrotum so that he could return to the field. The inconvenience came at the bottom of a ruck and also included the loss of four teeth. Unfortunately, Buck - who is still revered by All Black fans - had his gallantry rewarded only by a swift blow to the head which left him concussed.
He is hugely animated by the latest performance of his old team. "It was pretty hard to keep down the emotion," he reported. "There was a lot of pressure on these guys to perform and they all put their hands up. There have been different reasons for the All Black failures in World Cups but the one that has been ever present is terrific pressure. On Sunday the boys just shoved it aside.
"The French, we all know, can be tricky, but if New Zealand produce anything like the game they delivered against Australia there shouldn't be a problem. If I have one sadness it is that Wales will not be involved in what could have been a great final - they were a credit to the tournament and should win the Six Nations hands down. Even with 14 men, they should have beaten the French but with a full team they would have done it by at least 20 points."
His other deep regret is the red card given to the young Welsh captain, Sam Warburton, a fellow back-rower who in a few weeks had impressed him as much as any modern player.
Shelford, ferocious though he was on the field, is not exactly sanguine about the dangers of violent play. He works zealously for a foundation which cares for the most serious victims of an extremely hard game. However, he says: "The bad thing was that judgment was made so quickly, without a second to consider what had happened truly, without any consultation with fellow officials or a proper look at the incident which technology could have provided. A yellow card would have been the right response."
Warburton has to rebuild his career now but Shelford is confident that it can happen seamlessly enough. He will learn from his experience, as the All Blacks proved they had so demonstrably with the depth of their performance against the Wallabies.
Henry spoke of the dissecting of past All Black failures in the World Cup.
He said that the starting point of the campaign, which began in the rubble of quarter-final defeat by France in the last tournament, was an understanding that New Zealand, like no other rugby nation, had always put vast store in the legacy of each group of All Black players.
Every test match had to be won. Yet World Cup rugby made other demands, and most pressingly the need to understand the pacing of an effort and an understanding that sudden death brought new demands.
He suggested that the lesson might finally have been learned. At the coach's side was a man who has grown hugely these past few weeks. Brad Thorn, uniquely effective in league, in the colours of Australia, and one of rugby's most specialised positions at lock, spoke for the passion of this land yesterday.
He said: "The support we have had has been unbelievable ... they have been cheering us along from Stewart Island to the top of the North Island and people tell me that is pressure. For me, it's a lift. Growing up in Australia, I felt the same way, cheering the Blacks at World Cups. To be out on the field, receiving that, well, it's pretty special. Whatever happens there is sadness for me because this will be my last game in a black jersey."
Thorn is 36 and immense. He was stupendous against Australia, remorseless and playing as though he was going beyond his own skin. The Needle and Old Buck were particularly appreciative. A big wind is blowing in from the sea but the heart of a great sports nation has rarely beaten so serenely. New Zealand is at peace - for at least a few more days.
- Independent