On the evidence of his work when Argentina held out Tonga in the appetiser to Japan's boilover, referee Jaco Peyper should not be in any discussion about controlling any major playoff matches at the tournament.
Read more:
• Phil Gifford: The ABs World Cup quarter-final that would be a game for the ages
• Chris Rattue: Coaching masterclass puts Joseph front of ABs frame
• Dylan Cleaver: Fact or fiction? The truth about this Rugby World Cup
His performance in tandem with the work of TMO Rowan Kitt left you wondering how they earned their appointments. At one scrum the Pumas loose-head prop buckled and nosedived into the turf but the Tongan tight-head prop was penalised. What was that all about?
Tell us, then we could feel more connected to the game. A microphone hooked into the stadium speakers would have let Peyper tell us why he made that decision.
Japan is at the forefront of technology and I'll wager they could sort out a solution for the next round of matches if World Rugby allowed them.
Instead all of us and the players were left in a vacuum. I watched the match with a former top-class rugby player and we shrugged our shoulders throughout about Peyper's rulings.
On another occasion, Peyper and Kitt decided after brief viewings that Tongan wing David Halaifonua had been tackled into touch when another angle strongly suggested he had been shoulder-charged.
Earlier Peyper was well out of position and unsighted yet awarded a try to the Pumas hooker who lost control of the ball. It was one episode in a succession of baffling judgments.
Peyper's performance built a strong case around comments from Tongan coach Toutai Kepu that tier two nations got their share of poor decisions.
The mediocrity of a number of referees struggling to cope with the game's convoluted laws has been the shady handbrake on the sunny tournament.
We saw the uncertainty of Monsieur Garces when the All Blacks opened their programme and that perplexing theme has continued through games and into the after-match as well.
Officials cited and banned Reece Hodge for three weeks but that vigilance and judgement on others has been as erratic as Peyper's performance.
Love your rugby? Click here to subscribe to our new Premium newsletter for extensive Rugby World Cup coverage.