The Daily Telegraph said that he 'gifted' the All Blacks the Bledisloe Cup in 2013 while the Herald's Gregor Paul said he had a 'shocker' in last November's clash in Ireland.
All Blacks and Ireland agree: Ref had a shocker
The Belfast Telegraph went as far as saying he 'failed in his duty of care to the players'.
Peyper has also handed out five yellow cards to All Blacks players in his last three tests.
Garces also controlled an All Blacks' victory over Wales early last year.
Poite is the only one to have refereed a Lions' test before. He was also in charge of the third test in 2013 when the Lions wrapped up the series with a convincing 41-16 win over Australia.
Records in All Blacks matches:
Jaco Peyper - 11 tests, 10 All Blacks wins, 1 draw
All Blacks 54 Argentina 15, 2012
All Blacks 27 Australia 16, 2013
All Blacks 33 Argentina 15, 2013
All blacks 26 France 19, 2013
All Blacks 28 England 27, 2014
All Blacks 12 Australia 12, 2014
All Blacks 25 Samoa 16, 2015
All Blacks 36 Wales 22, 2016
All Blacks 42 Australia 8, 2016
All Blacks 37 Argentina 17, 2016
All Blacks 21, Ireland 9, 2016
Jerome Garces - 8 tests, 8 All Blacks wins
All Blacks 51 Scotland 22, 2012
All Blacks 28 Argentina 13, 2013
All Blacks 36 England 13, 2014
All Blacks 14 South Africa 10, 2014
All Blacks 27 South Africa 20, 2015
All Blacks 20 South Africa 18, 2015 RWC
All Blacks 46 Wales 6, 2016
All Blacks 57 South Africa 15, 2016
Romain Poite - 6 tests, 6 All Blacks wins
All Blacks 60 Ireland 0, 2012
All Blacks 21 Argentina 5, 2012
All Blacks 29 South Africa 15, 2013
All Blacks 24 Scotland 16, 2014
All Blacks 51 Australia 20, 2014
All Blacks 29 Australia 9, 2016