Kearney's loyalty is admirable but it was pointed out the same players had also struggled in back-to-back losses to the Panthers and Dragons before again falling short against the Eels.
Right-side pair Thompson and Johnson have repeatedly been exposed on defence and the Kiwis playmaker has lacked confidence and consistency on attack.
Hoffman's tackling has also been below par, while his left-edge partner Kata looked off the pace in his return after a fortnight out with a calf injury.
Kearney is aware of his side's shortcomings but maintains consistent selections are required to teach his players how to bounce back and improve. Patience is wearing thin in the coaches box but he refused to put his team on notice and said selections would be reassessed again next week.
"When we talk about getting consistency, it's about me giving these guys that I've trusted (another chance)," he said.
"They have the ability to do the job and that's why I'm persevering with the selection choices that I've made.
"My job is to persevere with them and make sure they're getting the education and awareness so that they do become consistent NRL players."
Kearney's persistence with Johnson and 299-game veteran Hoffman is hardly surprising, but eyebrows have been raised by Thompson's continued selection, with hard-working youngster Bunty Afoa waiting in the wings.
However, Kearney would not be drawn on the reasons behind Thompson's form slump and reiterated his belief in the 28-year-old.
"I know what Bodene is capable of and I have trust that he can get the job done and I'm pretty confident that he'll do the job for us this week."
Meanwhile, veteran wing Manu Vatuvei will play for the club's Intrust Super Premiership side in Sunday's clash against Blacktown in Sydney.
Injuries have restricted the 31-year-old to just one NRL appearance this season, with a recurring knee problem spoiling a 53 minute outing in the round three loss to Canterbury in Dunedin.
He then suffered a calf injury at the captain's run before the round 10 loss to Penrith, but a successful return will put him back in the frame to face the Bulldogs at Mt Smart Stadium on June 23.
"It's a bit of a risk in my mind to take him over the Gold Coast without a run under his belt so he'll get that opportunity this weekend."