Instead he remained one of league's black sheep.
Cherry-Evans was booed when he appeared on the MCG big screen as he ran out in the fallout over his much publicised NRL contract backflip. Just as he was recently at Suncorp Stadium while playing for Manly.
And there were few cheers when his game two stint ended, capped by a team-high five missed tackles.
He may avoid a game three jeering at Suncorp Stadium on July 8 with Cronk set to return from injury and form NRL No7 Ben Hunt breathing down his neck.
Cherry-Evans polarised the public when he backflipped on a Gold Coast NRL deal and stayed at Manly on a "lifetime" A$10 million deal.
Yet he found a way to bring Origin's tribal rivalry together on Wednesday night when inundated by boos.
There was plenty of pressure - but no excuses.
Last year Cherry-Evans struggled to step up in Cronk's absence in Origin II after having just one training session thanks to a knee niggle.
This time Cherry-Evans had a full preparation in the Maroons' camp. Yet it seemed to be the same old result.
Meninga said he was "pretty sure" Cronk would return for Origin III after the halfback flexed his regenerative powers by returning early from a broken wrist in 2014's game three. But he still felt compelled to defend Cherry-Evans.
"They ran at Daly quite often," he said. "I don't know how many tackles he made but it was considerable."
Smith empathised with Cherry-Evans' plight.
"There's no doubt they sent Ryan Hoffman at him a few times," he said.
"I think he was up to 20 tackles at halftime.
"The effort was great and when you're only making 15 or 16 tackles a week for your club ... it does take a bit of starch out of your attack.
"It's his second game starting at No7 in Origin - it takes guys a fair while to get used to that role."
- AAP