"In another life I would," said Taupau. "I've secured my future with Manly, signed right up to 2020. It's all league for me now. But if I had my time over, in another lifetime, I would go over and play the NFL."
As demonstrated by the Jarryd Hayne foray, it's extremely difficult to convert raw athletic potential into an NFL-ready product, especially without the years in the bank.
"It's high risk," admitted Taupau. "I would be out for 12 or so months - out of rugby league - without being paid and I don't really have the luxury."
Taupau appeals as someone who could have made the switch - with his raw power, aggression and agility - and watching him hurl 50 metre gridiron style passes at Kiwis training makes you wonder if he could have been the first running back who could also play quarterback.
But Taupau has committed to the NRL over the next four years, a bonus for the Kiwis. He has been a formidable force in the test arena since his debut in 2014, recognized as one of the best impact forwards in the sport.
His game is built on hours in the gym, which has earned him the title of the NRL's strongest man.
"Strongest man - it's a crack up," said Taupau. "If only they knew. It's hard. It's really hard to be on, 100 percent, in the gym every day or every second day. It takes a massive toll on my nervous system; most of the time you feel like you get hit by a train."
The relentless workouts in the gym (Taupau can bench press almost 200kg and has recorded a 300kg deadlift) has a double benefit. Not only providing the physical platform for his game, but also the mental framework.
"I've conditioned myself mentally - it's all a mental game," said Taupau. "You can be so fatigued, so much lactic acid build up in your muscles but if your mind is set you can conquer anything. I have conditioned my mental strength to keep pushing to the limits...there is never an end for me."
It feels like Taupau has been under-used on this tour, averaging around 30 minutes a game compared to 40 or more in the Stephen Kearney era.
Giving the 1.90m, 112kg prop more minutes could be crucial in Monday's Four Nations final at Anfield, not that Taupau seems to mind.
"I'm happy wherever I am, whenever I play," said Taupau. "I'm never content, never complacent. Even if it is just coming on for ten minutes and racking up as many metres as I can...that's what I'll do."
Autex - Proud sponsors of New Zealand rugby league since 1981