But it is doubtful whether a fit Hodges would have made any difference as the 2008 and 2011 premiers were swamped in their 10th successive finals series.
Next Friday Manly meet the winner of Sunday's elimination final between Melbourne and Canterbury at AAMI Park and Anthony Watmough (dangerous throw), Jamie Lyon (dangerous throw) and Kieran Foran (high tackle) face nervous waits over their availability.
Souths opened their account in the 11th minute when Reynolds latched onto a Dylan Walker grubber.
With the Rabbitohs totally dominating the forward exchanges, Souths added to their lead in the 18th minute when Reynolds kicked for his halves partner Luke Keary to cross. And the favourites picked up a 12-0 lead on the back of Walker and Kirisome Auva'a combining for a 60m move on the Rabbitohs' left hand side.
It was around the same time in the 2013 preliminary final that Manly fought their way back from 14-0 down, but Souths just surged on this occasion.
With Manly on the back foot and Hodges struggling with the injury, winger Lote Tuqiri outjumped his opposite Jorge Taufua for a spectacular touchdown from a Reynolds highball in the 27th minute.
Manly hardly had the ball out of their own half in the first 40 minutes and Alex Johnston added to their misery in the 35th minute when he scored out wide off a set play, that came after he dropped the ball over the line in the 23rd minute.
That sent the Rabbitohs to the break 22-0 ahead and the one-way traffic continued in the second half.
Reynolds grubbered for himself to add his second just two minutes after the restart and Walker crossed off a set move through some more soft goalline defence from Manly in the 52nd minute.
Johnston then streaked away for his double in the 55th minute for Souths to gap the lead to 40-0.
Manly finally scored in the 64th minute through Brett Stewart and Jamie Lyon added to that four minutes later.
Tom Symonds added to that in another consolation effort for Manly in the 75th minute, before Cheyse Blair added Manly's fourth in the shadows of fulltime.
- AAP