Maguire is stepping down to take on the New South Wales State of Origin side when he would have preferred to keep both coaching roles.
New Zealand Rugby League saw a conflict of interest, according to Australian legend Greg Alexander, who raised his own questions about the controversial decision.
On this side of the Tasman, Endacott was well placed to comment after coaching the Kiwis through two World Cup campaigns between 1994 and 2000, and in 2000 was named England’s Coach of the Year for taking Wigan to the Grand Final in the Super League.
“Getting rid of Michael Maguire is actually going to bite us,” former Kiwis, Warriors and Wigan coach Frank Endacott said.
Rather than making the call, Endacott felt New Zealand Rugby League could have worked through any perceived conflict of interest to hang on to their man.
“They should have at least given it one campaign of the State of Origin to see how it worked out,” Endacott said.
“And if it worked out well, then everything carries on as normal.”
“There was never a conflict of interest. Michael is a level-headed man. If anything it would have helped the Kiwis because working with the Australian players in the State of Origin he’s going to learn about those players and have more information on them.”
Meanwhile, across the ditch, former Kangaroo Greg Alexander was left bemused by the decision.
“Obviously the board have been swayed and have said ‘it’s not a good look’. They thought there was a conflict of interest,” Alexander said.
“That’s all it can be. It’s the optics of it.”
“The end of the origin is the middle of July, once you’ve finished that third game you’re finished. Then he’s got another 12 weeks before international footy rolls around.”