"There are reasons they won, as there are some great players there and the Aussies and Kiwis really took over those awards.
"But it's up to us now to prove we should, and get our names up there.''
The 22-year-old Tomkins has announced himself as a world class fullback during the Four Nations tournament, and could not be contained in the pivotal win over New Zealand.
Despite his form, he has endured a love-hate relationship with England fans, who perceive him to be arrogant.
Tomkins admits he was over-awed in the 2009 final when Australia cruised to a 44-16 win thanks to a barnstorming second-half performance.
However, he believes the team showed enough quality in the 36-20 defeat to the Kangaroos at Wembley earlier in the tournament to fuel the belief they could spoil Darren Lockyer's farewell party.
"I think it is a very different situation to what we were two years ago, personally and as a team,'' Tomkins said.
"I think we were bigger underdogs in 2009, we probably thought we didn't have much chance of beating them.
"This year we feel that we have the team to do it.''
- AAP