While he was magnificent last season, Ohoka Punter always had the look of a genuine Grand Circuit star, with the scope and stamina to take the step into the big time.
Last season he was not only good enough to beat Adore Me, Franco Nelson and Border Control in the race of the season, the Woodlands Northern Derby, but downed Aussie hero Guaranteed in the Victoria Derby.
"It is disappointing he has an issue with his leg again but we will look after him and give him all the time he needs," said Herlihy.
He wasn't the only disappointed trainer yesterday as Tim Butt reluctantly withdrew imported trotter Peak from the A$200,000 ($216,100) Glenferrie Farm Challenge in Sydney on March 2.
Butt thought he was getting on top of soreness issues with the talented chestnut but now knows he won't make the great race, with his place in the five-strong New Zealand team being taken by The Fiery Ginga.
Meanwhile, New Zealand's two Inter Dominion headliners Terror To Love and Smolda have drawn to dominate their $50,000 heat at Addington on Saturday night.
Terror To Love drew barrier one in the 2600m mobile event, with Smolda at two and the rest of the six-horse field given no hope.
While a top two finish would be good enough to get both pacers an invite to the A$750,000 Inter Dominion Final on March 2, a key question will be whether whoever finishes second still wants to go.