MacDonald's skills as a selector are what sets him apart and they have been a missing link at the Blues. They weren't a strength of predecessors Tana Umaga or John Kirwan. It takes intuition to know when a player is ready and where his or her best position is and not all good coaches are good selectors. It was, as has been widely established, a great strength of former All Blacks coach Steve Hansen's.
Ioane would have been deeply disappointed to have been on the outer at the start of the season. The man who averaged 79 minutes per 16 games for the Blues in 2018 and 78 minutes over the same number of games last year played just 12 minutes over the first five rounds this year.
He wasn't required to put his boots on for the Blues' first two matches (pre-Covid), and wasn't required for the two-match trip to South Africa.
But Ioane needed careful handling after becoming close to burned out over the previous two years – last year Hansen made it plain in explaining Ioane's absence from the World Cup squad that the loose forward was playing "like a tired athlete" - and the form of Sotutu and Tom Robinson at the Blues meant they simply had to keep going. Fortunately for Ioane, his big break came when Sotutu and Robinson succumbed to injuries and he maintained the momentum all the way to a test debut against Australia in Brisbane.
MacDonald clearly had a plan for Ioane and he stuck with it, while, importantly, keeping a man with big All Black ambitions fully engaged and focused despite a lack of game time, and that balancing act can be difficult to achieve. The end result was two test caps, and Ioane was one of the All Blacks' best in the recent 38-0 victory over Argentina in Newcastle.
Sotutu showed he has the pace and power to belong at test level and that he is an ideal impact player from the reserves bench – something the All Blacks haven't had since Ardie Savea demanded a starting role – and Hodgman played the game of his life for the All Blacks against the Wallabies at Eden Park.
Clarke, Ioane, Sotutu and Hodgman are all going places in a rugby sense once they leave the confines of their hotel and MacDonald deserves acknowledgement because this year he gave them the perfect start.