When a Samoan can't play for France, because he's deemed to be a New Zealander, it's apparent that rugby's eligibility laws are in need of urgent fixing.
The strange case of David Smith, the former Blues and Hurricanes wing, has highlighted the shambles over which World Rugby presides when it comes to the rules around international qualification.
Smith was called up to the French national squad this week when injuries struck - on the basis he qualified on residency, having lived in France for more than the required three years. But after he turned up, he declared he'd played in a sevens tournament for New Zealand in 2008.
That appearance for the New Zealand sevens, according to World Rugby, meant Smith, who came to Mount Albert Grammar on scholarship from Samoa in 2003 when he was 16, was a Kiwi.
The ruling was hard to fathom on two levels. Firstly, what does sevens have to do with anything? It's clearly, in all aspects, totally detached from rugby. It is not so much a derivation of the code, but an entirely separate code.