Paul Marshall has headed off a 21-strong field, including incumbent Neil Emblen and former All Whites captain Danny Hay, to land the plum coaching role at Waitakere United for the ASB Premiership and O-League campaigns.
The club's board confirmed Marshall's appointment on Monday night after an apparent head-to-head with Emblen, who had turned down two earlier offers to remain at the Premiership-winning club.
"It was a really difficult decision," said chairman Peter Bult.
"The four-strong subcommittee could not make a decision so it came back to the full board. We offered the job to Emblen twice but he turned it down when, at that stage, we made it clear we wanted his sole focus on the club rather than continuing to work with both Waitakere and the All Whites."
Marshall does, however, have the club's blessing to continue his role with girls' soccer at Mt Albert Grammar.