Did Marcus Rashford dive or was there contact?
Well it's never a good sign when the opposing manager starts off by saying "I'm not saying he cheated. I'm using the word 'deceived.'".
That was Swansea manager Paul Clement's take on the controversial penalty in his side's 1-1 draw with Manchester United this morning.
"Maybe cheat is a word I'd use another time but on this occasion I think he deceived the ref," Clement told the Independent newspaper.
Rashford has provided us with some memorable moments in his fledgling career, but there was nothing to admire in the way he persuaded referee Neil Swarbrick to point to the spot.