Marco Rojas hopes to start in Wellington on Wednesday - and if the All Whites are to have any chance of redemption, he probably should.
The New Zealand midfielder was on the bench at the Azteca after being out with injury for most of the last few months. It was understandable that he wasn't considered a 90-minute proposition last Thursday but the All Whites can't afford to leave their best attacking weapon on the bench at home.
"It was a relief to get out there after so long," said Rojas, who made an instant impact in Mexico. "It would be great to start in Wellington and I hope I can force my way in."
He should be one of a number of changes for the second leg. Storm Roux will come in for the suspended Leo Bertos, while Chris James is a certainty to replace Jeremy Christie in midfield. Shane Smeltz, New Zealand's most intelligent player in the attacking third, must also be included.
It would be dramatic by his standards but Herbert may be tempted to change formation. The All Whites were swamped in midfield last Thursday and switching to a 4-5-1 may allow them to match up better against the versatile Mexican team.