Ninth in the 2012 time trial was the closest the Spaniard ever came to the rainbow stripes. In any case, it is a moot point, as Contador - the man they called El Pistolero - fired his last shot at the Vuelta last week.
He did it in some style, too, winning the final competitive stage of his career on the Angliru having spent three weeks attacking the peloton.
A true fairy-tale ending.
Or was it? Contador's retirement was fascinating to see, particularly in Spain. There, you would hardly have known that Froome had won. The front page of Marca on the final day breathlessly heralded the retirement of a national icon 'Un Heroe!'.
The next day, having soaked up the adulation of thousands of fans on the Paseo del Prado, Contador returned to his home town where thousands more feted him with chants of "Un ano mas" (one more year).
All entirely understandable.
Contador won seven grand tours. He was the most successful grand tour rider of his generation and a thrilling racer to the end.
Except for one thing: he was a convicted drugs cheat.
Contador tested positive for clenbuterol at the 2010 Tour. Although he claimed contaminated meat was to blame, his strong links to the Operacion Puerto scandal (again, he pleaded his innocence) sealed his guilt in most minds.
So, while he found himself feted by one section of the cycling community (even some Spanish journalists cheered his win atop Angliru), he was written off by another. Good riddance to another who helped to tarnish the sport.
Contador's legacy is complicated and neatly sums up where cycling finds itself: the double standards, the hypocrisy, its struggles to move on from its past.
Should he be regarded as an all-time great? After all, he served his ban, was docked two of his grand tours and still managed seven, placing him fourth on the all-time list.
If you dismiss his achievements, should you not also write off Eddy Merckx, widely considered cycling's greatest, who tested positive three times? Or Tom Simpson, found with amphetamines in his system when he died on the Tour de France in 1967.
Why is it that Lance Armstrong is banished for good while others he cheated with run teams?
There are no easy answers.