His fans point to the fact India are yet to lose a test in which Binny has played, leading one to draw the conclusion that his selection was primarily to fulfil the role of lucky mascot. But before 40 overs had even been played, it seemed clear that the fates were not on the side of the tourists.
Not that this performance can be in any way attributed to bad luck, rather a ruthless bowling performance, albeit in very favourable conditions, from an England attack that never gave their opponents the slightest whiff of an opportunity.
This is the first time any of this Indian side have ever played in a five-test series and it showed.
In unfamiliar conditions, India's top order have been worked out by England's bowlers and the results could scarcely be more obvious.
It was a day when a persistent pigeon spent more time on The Oval square than Gautam Gambhir - the recalled opening batsman's golden duck leaves his series average in single figures and his test career all but over.
This was supposed to be the series when India's young guns announced themselves on the world stage. Instead Cheteshwar Pujara and Virat Kohli have made a combined 325 runs in their 18 innings, averaging 23.44 and 12.66 respectively - still some way to go then if they are to get close to being the new Dravid and Tendulkar.
However, this was not a day simply of Indian ineptitude, but rather a day when England's support bowlers joined in the party.
Much has been made of the home side's over-reliance on James Anderson and Stuart Broad, but England's success on day one truly came thanks to Chris's Jordan and Woakes, who not so much walked through the door opened by their more illustrious bowling partners as blew it off its hinges.
They finished with three wickets each, a reward for unluckier spells earlier in the series, and a promising sign for England's 'new era'.
In the end, it was only another 10th-wicket partnership and a bloody-minded captain's knock from Dhoni that saved India from total embarrassment.
Even after only one day, they'll need a combination of bad weather and every one of Binny's four-leaf clover collection if they are to get anything from this match.
India 148 (MS Dhoni 86, Woakes 3-30, Jordan 3-32) England 62-0 (Robson 33 not out, Cook 24 not out).
- The Independent