Yes, if faced with an emerald-tinged batting monster and stifling humidity, he might consider otherwise, especially if memories of "Newlands" and "45" are rekindled from his captaincy debut in January 2013.
Since the turn of the century at Brisbane, if a team chooses to bat and the first session is negotiated with the loss of two wickets or less, their chances of avoiding defeat are high.
On only one occasion in the last 15 years - New Zealand's 67-2 in 2004 - has that occurred. That side went on to lose by an innings and 156 runs after being bundled out for 76 in their second innings against the might of Glenn McGrath, Jason Gillespie, Michael Kasprowicz and Shane Warne.
In fact, there is only one instance when a team has chosen to bat and been more than two wickets down at lunch since 2000. Again, it was New Zealand, who slumped to 94-4 in 2008 and lost by nine wickets.
Teams sent in on what captains assume is a juicy wicket also prosper.
These statistics might be skewed by the prowess of Australian opening pair Justin Langer and Matthew Hayden, who were indomitable in the early 2000s, but they are real.
A key example came in 2002 when England captain Nasser Hussain looked to put pressure on the hosts at the start of the Ashes. The visitors needed multiple applications of sunscreen. Australia were 125-1 at lunch, 364-2 at stumps and eventually won by 384 runs.
Martin Guptill, Tom Latham, Kane Williamson and Ross Taylor can take solace. If they endure the first session, they will have set a platform from which their team can feel secure.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Get involved in Dream Team Cricket Tipping this summer
Dream Team has two brand new games to help you follow and compete against your friends as you watch the 2015/16 summer of cricket. Plus be in to win signed cricket bats and cash prizes every week.
International Cricket Tipping includes all formats of international cricket including New Zealand's home and away series against Australia.
While NZ Cricket Tipping returns with all the action from the Goergie Pie Super Smash, Ford Trophy and Plunket Shield.