For this summer's Tests, against Ireland and Australia, England chose a batch of Dukes balls made in 2018 precisely because they "hoop", or swing, and move around off their proud seams.
Mark Adair, who backed up Murtagh excellently, though something of a novice, moved the ball up and down the slope from the Pavilion end, as did Stuart Broad and Olly Stone, who made an impressive debut by swinging the ball at high pace - Stone's ball to dismiss Andy Balbirnie was a superlative outswinger.
Throw in dry pitches - which -appear to be the inevitable concomitant of modern drainage - and -extra grass, which is required to bind dry pitches together, and no wonder Tests in England are getting shorter. This one-off Test is scheduled for four days - at 98 overs per day, although only 81.5 were managed in the heat of day one - which should prove more than enough.
James Anderson was, unfortunately for England, not fit enough to benefit from the conditions here because he might have out-Murtaghed Murtagh. Even in Anderson's absence, if England can set Ireland a three-figure target, the combination of Broad, the brand of ball and scoreboard pressure, -together with some help from England's two spinners, might yet avert embarrassment on the eve of the Ashes. It is not as if Australia's batsmen, practising at Southampton, are scoring many more runs.
Has there been a World Cup hangover? Overtly, yes, in that the five England players involved in that triumph have scored eight runs so far. But hubris and complacency are not likely to be the culprits so much as a natural fatigue - and unfamiliarity with the red ball's behaviour. Given little more than a fortnight between the World Cup and the Ashes, this inaugural Test against Ireland was the best warm-up in the circumstances, but a championship game or two in -addition would have been ideal.
It was only after tea that England began to do the basics as well as Ireland had in the first two sessions. when they dismissed England in the first and reached 127 for two in the second. Their bowlers, led by Murtagh, bowled fuller and straighter, and therefore swung and seamed the ball more than England's; Ireland's batsmen played later - the ball under their eyes - and straighter; and Gary Wilson outperformed the rusty Jonny Bairstow as wicketkeeper, and Paul Stirling accepted a low catch at first slip while Joe Root dropped one.
On a day when 20 wickets fell - the most on the opening day of a Test at Lord's - England lurched from 36 for one to 43 for seven, then 85 all out before lunch. Some critics accuse their batting of being inconsistent but, as a team of shot-players and hitters rather than traditional batsmen, England have a regular nightmare.
This collapse bettered the one in Barbados earlier this year when they lost nine wickets in a session to be dismissed for 77; last year New Zealand swung them out for 58 in Auckland; in Dhaka in 2016 they had lost all 10 wickets in a session against Bangladesh. In an age of global warming an annual England batting collapse is more certain than a harvest.
Murtagh's cleverest wicket was that of Bairstow who, as a keeper-bat, was at least one place too high, and arguably two, as was Moeen Ali. Bairstow took guard a couple of feet outside the crease to cut down the amount of Murtagh's swing and was warned by the umpires to go back so as not to damage the pitch. Whether he was distracted by the pursuit of this tactic, or by the posting of a short and straight mid-off, Bairstow went for a booming drive next ball and was bowled through the gate.
After tea England clicked, though not before Ireland had gone into the lead. Balbirnie timed the ball against pace and spin for a delightful 50 instead of trying to hit too hard, like his England counterparts. Broad and Stone spurred England back into the game, bowling the full length required, but Kevin O'Brien hung in and with the help of Murtagh's mowing took Ireland to a lead of 100, and with Boyd Rankin's blocking to 122 in all.
Terrible dress rehearsals have been known to precede performances which are all right on the night.
The Daily Telegraph