Broad didn't endear himself when he rode his luck, taking a long-handled approach to thrash three fours and even enjoyed a life when Shaun Marsh grassed a chance in the outfield.
TV commentator Shane Warne appeared to delight in watching Broad struggle against the frequent bouncers from Aussie trio Mitchell Starc, Pat Cummins and Josh Hazlewood.
"Anything above medium pace and Stuart Broad struggles," the former champion legspinner said.
Warne later tweeted: "Wasn't pretty to watch the English lower order try and play the short ball!"
There was no respite for Broad with ball in hand despite some early success.
Broad silenced the crowd when he made short work of rookie Cameron Bancroft, claiming the opener caught behind for five to reduce Australia to 7-1 in the fourth over.
But he still couldn't escape criticism.
Former Australian captain Ian Chappell took aim at Broad for squandering the DRS after calling for an lbw shout against Shaun Marsh to be reviewed despite appearing too high.
Marsh survived the review but Broad wasn't so fortunate after Chappell let rip.
"I tell you what, if I was the captain, I would be totally ignoring Stuart Broad because he thinks everything is out when he is bowling," he said.
"I mean, so do most bowlers, but Broad more so.
"If I was Joe Root I would be turning to the keeper immediately so I couldn't see Stuart Broad."
Smith and Marsh's stand — the first significant partnership of the innings — dug the home team out of serious trouble at a ground where Australia haven't lost a test match since 1988, and where England haven't recorded a victory in 31 years.