Only one home in Rotorua sold at a loss of $58,000, which was a home in Pomare purchased in March 2017 for $307,000 and resold in February 2019 for $249,000.
CoreLogic senior property economist Kelvin Davidson said the drive in resale profits was not surprising as house prices in the city continued to rise.
"You can sell for a resale profit above the original price even after holding the property for a short time," he said.
The couple had just got married and moved back to Rotorua, where they both grew up.
"It's been a great home over the years," McFadyen, the principal at Ngongotahā Primary School, said. "We have raised our two sons [Matthew, 9, and Joshua, 8] in it and have hundreds of good memories there."
McFadyen said he and his wife bought their single-storey, three-bedroom home on Hodgkins St for the "great neighbourhood, quiet cul de sac, brilliant neighbours".
"It was close to the park for the kids and the dog and it is a really good house to entertain friends," he said.
On May 6 this year, the couple put their family home on the market.
"We just needed something bigger. The boys are growing up and we need the second living area," McFadyen said.
Two days later on May 8, the couple had an offer on their home and it went unconditional on May 24.
"It sold immediately," McFadyen said, and it also sold at a profit.